Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Quote:Let me know the next time that Andrew Luck does not absolutely pick us apart with ease.

 

Gabbert beat him.

 

Gabbert.

 

And speaking of picks, yeah... he throws plenty.

Quote:Gabbert beat him.

 

Gabbert.

 

And speaking of picks, yeah... he throws plenty.

 

 Yes, Gabbert did actually beat Luck when they were both starting in a game in 2012. Here's the proof for those of you out there that just don't believe it:

 

http://www.pro-football-reference.com/bo...230clt.htm

 

I still think most people don't know how it actually happened. Heck, I watched the game and I still don't know how Gabbert pulled it off.

 

I guess it was the 80 yard pass from Gabbert to Shorts that did it, you know, the one that took Gabberts passing yards for the game from 75 yards to 155 yards.

Colin Kapernick. Not too long ago, he was a future star. Lots of people still see him that way, but the truth is that if you force him to play in the pocket, he's below average. He easily tops my list.

 

Though he'd be an easy choice, Andy Dalton doesn't make my list. That's mostly because I think he stopped being overrated two years ago, and is now recognized for the very average game manager that he is.

Aaron Rodgers

Quote:Aaron Rodgers

 

Quote:Chip Kelly

Amen!

Romo

Better yet...all NFC East QBs.

Quote:

#1 player in the NFL and top 10 qb of all time? he's good, and a top 5 qb but not one of the best ever. I'm sick of hearing how great he is.

Quote:Let me know the next time that Andrew Luck does not absolutely pick us apart with ease.

Second Indy game last year...


Charlie Whitehurst picked us apart more than Luck.

Peyton Manning.  Overinflated stats due to Julius Thomas.

Quote:#1 player in the NFL and top 10 qb of all time? he's good, and a top 5 qb but not one of the best ever. I'm sick of hearing how great he is.

 

 As much as I would like to agree with you,   as a fan of another NFC North team,   I truly believe he's the best QB in the division not only at present but in at least the last 45 years.   This of course includes the old NFC Central Division.  

 

Aaron Rodgers is the primary reason the Packers won the Super Bowl in the 2010 season,  4 straight division titles since then, and 6 straight playoff appearances.   When Rodgers was younger,  he took too many sacks.   In recent seasons,   I don't see any flaws in his game. 

Quote:Second Indy game last year...


Charlie Whitehurst picked us apart more than Luck.

 

Sad when 250 yards, 65% comp percentage and a 100 QB rating is his worst game against us.

 

But yeah..he's, um, overrated.

 

He plays for the Colts. I don't like him either. But to pretend like he isn't an elite QB, and likely to be the best QB in the league at some point, is just living in denial. We should just be thankful that Grigson has done such a piss poor job of putting running backs and offensive line around him or he'd be that much better.

Quote:Gabbert beat him.

 

Gabbert.

 

And speaking of picks, yeah... he throws plenty.

It was his third start in his rookie season. 

 

3rd start. 

 

Andrew Luck has also led his team to about 20x the amount of wins. 

Can mike vick be an answer?

Sam Bradford.  

Quote:Can mike vick be an answer?

In 2005, maybe. Kind of like Vince Young in 2006.

 Kaepernick, Le'veon Bell, Eddie Lacey

Coach: Chip Kelly

Colin Kapernick for one. As well as Eli Manning. List could go on and on. 

Quote:Sad when 250 yards, 65% comp percentage and a 100 QB rating is his worst game against us.


But yeah..he's, um, overrated.


He plays for the Colts. I don't like him either. But to pretend like he isn't an elite QB, and likely to be the best QB in the league at some point, is just living in denial. We should just be thankful that Grigson has done such a [BAD WORD REMOVED] poor job of putting running backs and offensive line around him or he'd be that much better.

And he did nothing until the 3rd quarter...


And he gets beat by good playoff teams.


I'm not saying he's not really good, but people try to say he's elite and some go as far as to say he's the best in the NFL. I'm sorry, he's not either. That's overrated.


Let me know when he throws less than 10 ints in a season or at least stops making a bonehead rookie level throw or two per game. Then maybe he'll live up to where everyone hypes him to be.