Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Quote:Mack by just a little

 

Mike Evans vs. Kevin White

Now that I get the thread. Mike Evans and it isn't even close.

 

Clowney or Leonard Williams.

Quote:Now that I get the thread. Mike Evans and it isn't even close.


Clowney or Leonard Williams.

Easily Clowney. Was considered best defensive prospect in a decade.


Kevin White or Julio Jones

Quote:Mack by just a little


Mike Evans vs. Kevin White

Yea I agree but the time Mack was 23 while Fowler is only 20.

Quote:Easily Clowney. Was considered best defensive prospect in a decade.


Kevin White or Julio Jones

Julio. Better track record. Very similar players though.


Leonard Williams v Aaron Donald

Quote:Julio. Better track record. Very similar players though.


Leonard Williams v Aaron Donald

 

Williams as a prospect. 

 

Next:

 

Jonathan Martin vs Andrus Peat

Quote:Williams as a prospect. 

 

Next:

 

Jonathan Martin vs Andrus Peat

 

Andrus Peat.

 

 

Jonathan Martin is already on his 3rd team.  The SNF game vs. the Bears in which DE Willie Young schooled him jumps out immediately.

 

 

Darius Slay vs. Trae Waynes

Wayne


Dorian Green-Beckham vs. Kelvin Benjamin (character issues vs age as prospects)

Dgb.


Tyler Eifert vs Maxx Williams.

Quote:Dgb.


Tyler Eifert vs Maxx Williams.

Eifert loved him coming out

 

Geno Smith vs Brent Hundley 

Geno.


Jalen strong vs Brandin Cooks

Quote:Geno.


Jalen strong vs Brandin Cooks

 

Brandin Cooks.   Explosive impact ability.

 

 

Sharrif Floyd vs  Malcom Brown

Quote:Brandin Cooks.   Explosive impact ability.

 

 

Sharrif Floyd vs  Malcom Brown

Floyd


Jay Ajayi vs. Eddie Lacy

.

Quote:Floyd


Jay Ajayi vs. Eddie Lacy

That's a really tough one. Would Lacy have better college stats if Richardson wasn't alongside him ? Probably. I'll go Lacy.


Scherff or Joeckel ?

Quote:That's a really tough one. Would Lacy have better college stats if Richardson wasn't alongside him ? Probably. I'll go Lacy.


Scherff or Joeckel ?

Easy. Joeckel. Coming out, he was viewed as the best LT and consensus top 3 pick.

 

Justin Gilbert or Trae Waynes

Quote:Easy. Joeckel. Coming out, he was viewed as the best LT and consensus top 3 pick.

 

Justin Gilbert or Trae Waynes

 

Trae Waynes.    While Justin Gilbert has loads of upside potential,  his lack of maturity as a rookie is concerning.   On the other hand,  Trae Waynes seems mature beyond his years and has major upside potential as well.

 

 

Kyle Long vs. A.J. Cann

Quote:Andrus Peat.



Jonathan Martin is already on his 3rd team. The SNF game vs. the Bears in which DE Willie Young schooled him jumps out immediately.



Darius Slay vs. Trae Waynes

This is based on them as a prospect coming out of college. Martin on his 3 team and Willie Young schooling him has nothing to do with him as a prospect coming out of college though. Most thought Martin was a really good prospect coming out

Quote:This is based on them as a prospect coming out of college. Martin on his 3 team and Willie Young schooling him has nothing to do with him as a prospect coming out of college though. Most thought Martin was a really good prospect coming out

 

Based on the criteria you mentioned,  my choice would still be Andrus Peat,

 

On the other hand,  I would have chosen Justin Gilbert over Trae Waynes with the criteria of the game that you set up.   In hindsight though,  I didn't put enough weight on warning signs with Gilbert.