Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Full Version: Random Draft Thoughts
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
1.  We are now a month away from the NFL draft.  I've been a football fan for 38 years now, and a draftnik since 1983, and after all this time, I still get as excited as ever about the draft-though a cynic might suggest otherwise considering the Jaguars numerous draft day failures over the years.  The draft brings out the eternal optimist in almost every football fan.

 

2.  People have been discussing the expected W-L improvement the Jaguars should have given the schedule.  The thinking is since the Jaguars are playing against the NFC South, which had a losing team win the division, at minimum their interconference schedule should be soft enough to see the Jaguars eke out a few more wins.  However, I would not be so quick to pencil in the Tampa game as a W just yet.  If they hit on Winston, they could almost instantly turn into a formidable offense.  They have a very good offensive coordinator in Dirk Koetter, who turned Garrard into a respectable QB for a year or so.  They have just about all the skill position help for Winston they could want with Mike Evans and Vincent Jackson.  Those twin towers at WR (both 6-5), along with 2nd year TE Austin Sefarian Jenkins, would be tough matchups for just about any secondary.  If they can just get him healthy, Doug Martin can be a viable ground threat, but he hasn't been healthy since his rookie year.  However, there are several good RBs in this draft to help take the pressure off of him in case they have lost faith in Martin.  There is a lot of work to do, however, on the offensive line and on defense.  Tampa is certainly a winnable game for us, make no mistake.  But if they hit on Winston, it won't be an easy W.

 

3.  In the years before Bortles, much of the pre-draft debate would focus on the high bust rate at the QB position by those risk averse fans wanting to avoid a bust with a first round pick.  Unless I have missed a discussion on this, it is strange that we have not had similar discussions regarding the DE/OLB/Edge rushers in this draft, especially since we need one in a big way.  The fact is, there has been a very high bust rate among these teams that have chased pass rushers over the last 30 years.  Draft history over that time is littered with guys like Erik Kumerow, Mike Mamula, Aundray Bruce, Huey Richardson, John Thierry, Eric Curry, Bill Hawkins, Shante Carver, Cedric Jones, Regan Upshaw, Reinard Wilson, Jamal Reynolds, and Quentin Groves.  Interesting and perhaps cruel post script.  One of the few tweener successes over that time was one Hugh Douglas.

 

4.  Given that Demarco Murray stated a preference for staying with Dallas and that Romo stated he would have been willing to restructure his deal and take a paycut to accomodate keeping Murray, I can't help but think Jerry Jones, Stephen Jones and the Dallas brass was more apt to credit the Dallas offensive line with the success of the running game and offense than they were to give Demarco Murray credit for finally staying healthy and putting it all together.  Understanding Dallas is a team that likes star caliber players and likes making splashes during the draft, even though there is a need at RB for them, it would not be a total shock to see them go defense early and take advantage of a deep RB class and take a RB in the 2nd or 3rd round. 

 

5.  Cleveland had a desperate need for a WR last draft, and completely ignored the position in what was one of the deepest WR draft classes in NFL history.  There is talk that this year's WR class is just as deep, if not deeper, than last year's class.  I wonder if Cleveland will make the same mistake this year and not address the position.

 

6.  I still find Chicago-perhaps the longest running continuous 4-3 team I've seen-and Fox-traditionally a 4-3 coach-going to the 3-4 fascinating.  It will be interesting to watch them build their defense.

 

7.  A nightmare scenario for me would be for the Chargers to trade Phillip Rivers to either Tennessee or Houston in the effort to obtain Mariota.  Not that I care so much about the Chargers getting Mariota, but the thought of Phillip Rivers going to Houston or Tennessee is scary.  He has traditionally picked the Jaguars apart.  Though he is 34, he seemingly has avoided any major injuries, and should be a viable QB for at least a couple of seasons.  Part of the optimism Jaguars fans have had in the aftermath of all of these disastrous seasons is the idea that Bortles could ascend to the second best QB in the division this year.  If Rivers is introduced into this division, the proposition of Bortles being the second best QB in the division and Jacksonville becoming more viable for a possible wildcard become much tougher to make. 

Quote:1.  We are now a month away from the NFL draft.  I've been a football fan for 38 years now, and a draftnik since 1983, and after all this time, I still get as excited as ever about the draft-though a cynic might suggest otherwise considering the Jaguars numerous draft day failures over the years.  The draft brings out the eternal optimist in almost every football fan.

 

2.  People have been discussing the expected W-L improvement the Jaguars should have given the schedule.  The thinking is since the Jaguars are playing against the NFC South, which had a losing team win the division, at minimum their interconference schedule should be soft enough to see the Jaguars eke out a few more wins.  However, I would not be so quick to pencil in the Tampa game as a W just yet.  If they hit on Winston, they could almost instantly turn into a formidable offense.  They have a very good offensive coordinator in Dirk Koetter, who turned Garrard into a respectable QB for a year or so.  They have just about all the skill position help for Winston they could want with Mike Evans and Vincent Jackson.  Those twin towers at WR (both 6-5), along with 2nd year TE Austin Sefarian Jenkins, would be tough matchups for just about any secondary.  If they can just get him healthy, Doug Martin can be a viable ground threat, but he hasn't been healthy since his rookie year.  However, there are several good RBs in this draft to help take the pressure off of him in case they have lost faith in Martin.  There is a lot of work to do, however, on the offensive line and on defense.  Tampa is certainly a winnable game for us, make no mistake.  But if they hit on Winston, it won't be an easy W.

 

3.  In the years before Bortles, much of the pre-draft debate would focus on the high bust rate at the QB position by those risk averse fans wanting to avoid a bust with a first round pick.  Unless I have missed a discussion on this, it is strange that we have not had similar discussions regarding the DE/OLB/Edge rushers in this draft, especially since we need one in a big way.  The fact is, there has been a very high bust rate among these teams that have chased pass rushers over the last 30 years.  Draft history over that time is littered with guys like Erik Kumerow, Mike Mamula, Aundray Bruce, Huey Richardson, John Thierry, Eric Curry, Bill Hawkins, Shante Carver, Cedric Jones, Regan Upshaw, Reinard Wilson, Jamal Reynolds, and Quentin Groves.  Interesting and perhaps cruel post script.  One of the few tweener successes over that time was one Hugh Douglas.

 

4.  Given that Demarco Murray stated a preference for staying with Dallas and that Romo stated he would have been willing to restructure his deal and take a paycut to accomodate keeping Murray, I can't help but think Jerry Jones, Stephen Jones and the Dallas brass was more apt to credit the Dallas offensive line with the success of the running game and offense than they were to give Demarco Murray credit for finally staying healthy and putting it all together.  Understanding Dallas is a team that likes star caliber players and likes making splashes during the draft, even though there is a need at RB for them, it would not be a total shock to see them go defense early and take advantage of a deep RB class and take a RB in the 2nd or 3rd round. 

 

5.  Cleveland had a desperate need for a WR last draft, and completely ignored the position in what was one of the deepest WR draft classes in NFL history.  There is talk that this year's WR class is just as deep, if not deeper, than last year's class.  I wonder if Cleveland will make the same mistake this year and not address the position.

 

6.  I still find Chicago-perhaps the longest running continuous 4-3 team I've seen-and Fox-traditionally a 4-3 coach-going to the 3-4 fascinating.  It will be interesting to watch them build their defense.

 

7.  A nightmare scenario for me would be for the Chargers to trade Phillip Rivers to either Tennessee or Houston in the effort to obtain Mariota.  Not that I care so much about the Chargers getting Mariota, but the thought of Phillip Rivers going to Houston or Tennessee is scary.  He has traditionally picked the Jaguars apart.  Though he is 34, he seemingly has avoided any major injuries, and should be a viable QB for at least a couple of seasons.  Part of the optimism Jaguars fans have had in the aftermath of all of these disastrous seasons is the idea that Bortles could ascend to the second best QB in the division this year.  If Rivers is introduced into this division, the proposition of Bortles being the second best QB in the division and Jacksonville becoming more viable for a possible wildcard become much tougher to make. 
 

#1.) I agree I love the draft hope is in the air.

 

#2.) When I was watching the NFL replay game vs Pittsburgh I thought to myself the Bucs Offense wasnt horrible, the QB made a few good throws that Vincent & even Evans had dropped.  Their Oline wasnt nearly as bad as the Jaguars, but their Defense needs help.  If I was the Bucs I would think about drafting Leonard Williams not only because I think he is the best player in the draft but with McCoy injured its a need & if McCoy is healthy to start the season it would be a deadly duo as DT or Williams could be moved to the end either way he would be another beast on that line to help get at the passer & stop the run.

 

The Bucs are a lot like the Jaguars where they have need at several positions but If i was the GM of the Bucs I would do defense the first few rounds...

 

#3.) Agreed but I think drafting Leonard Williams is the least risky out of the top 5 prospects (in the rare case that he is available at #3).

 

#4.) Agreed, I think Murray is a great running back but it didnt hurt him to run behind one of the best Olines last season.  Good news for us to get their backup RT.  I think Jerry is listening to his advisors more because he didnt draft Johnny football last year as he publicly said he was tempted to do.  They might go Defense with the pick but probably Best Available player that meets their need.

 

#5.) The Browns might trade up for a QB after seeing the Johnny football collapse.

 

#6.)  I think the Bears will draft Shane Ray or Vic Beasley at #6.

Quote: 

#2.) When I was watching the NFL replay game vs Pittsburgh I thought to myself the Bucs Offense wasnt horrible, the QB made a few good throws that Vincent & even Evans had dropped.  Their Oline wasnt nearly as bad as the Jaguars, but their Defense needs help.  If I was the Bucs I would think about drafting Leonard Williams not only because I think he is the best player in the draft but with McCoy injured its a need & if McCoy is healthy to start the season it would be a deadly duo as DT or Williams could be moved to the end either way he would be another beast on that line to help get at the passer & stop the run.

 

The Bucs are a lot like the Jaguars where they have need at several positions but If i was the GM of the Bucs I would do defense the first few rounds...

 

 
The way I see it, I think the Bucs almost have to go QB.

 

While I am not as down on Glennon as I was, I still don't see him as the answer at QB.  They are in a position to land a potential franchise QB in Winston.  They need to take the QB.

 

I like the idea of pairing McCoy with Williams, and if the Bucs were not in a position to take a QB, I'd like that combo.
Every mock draft Ive ever read shows the Bucs taking Winston and they even write its a lock... so you are probably right.

Speaking of Doug Martin:

Quote:Doug Martin can likely be had in trade

Doug Martin | TB

(April 1, 2015 9:28 AM EDT)


ESPN Bucs reporter Pat Yasinskas believes Doug Martin can be had for a mid-round draft pick.

At this point, the Bucs would probably love a mid-rounder. Realistically, coming off two unimpressive seasons, Martin likely wouldn't bring back more than a late-round selection. He's already 26 and has been injury-prone the past two years. The Bucs are a candidate to address running back early in the draft.


SOURCE: ESPN.COM
Quote: 

#3.) Agreed but I think drafting Leonard Williams is the least risky out of the top 5 prospects (in the rare case that he is available at #3).

 

#4.) Agreed, I think Murray is a great running back but it didnt hurt him to run behind one of the best Olines last season.  Good news for us to get their backup RT.  I think Jerry is listening to his advisors more because he didnt draft Johnny football last year as he publicly said he was tempted to do.  They might go Defense with the pick but probably Best Available player that meets their need.

 

#5.) The Browns might trade up for a QB after seeing the Johnny football collapse.

 

#6.)  I think the Bears will draft Shane Ray or Vic Beasley at #6.
#3)  But where would he fit here?  Initially, I think you put him in at DT.

 

#4)  You are right about Jerry jones.  I think his son, Stephen, is calling the shots now.

 

#5)  The Browns would go up against overwhelming historical precedent by drafting two first round QBs in successive years, but that is a viable proposition for them to do just that.  That's just how big of a flop Manziel seems to be for them.

 

#6) Either pick would make a ton of sense for them.  Jared Allen is not a 3-4 OLB and has repeatedly said he isn't comfortable in that role at this stage of his career.  3-4 defenses need the stand up pass rusher who can get to the QB, and they will need someone who can get Aaron Rodgers, Matt Stafford, and Teddy Bridgewater on the ground.  In fact, in many ways that would make more sense than Shelton.  I like Shelton a LOT and think he will be an outstanding NT.  But given the depth of NT in this draft class, and given what the Bears have done in the past two offseasons to add DT prospects who could transition easily into a 3-4, pass rusher seems to be the biggest defensive need. 
Quote:Speaking of Doug Martin:

 
Good luck with them getting anything for him.
The Jets indicate they will run a base nickel defense.

 

Not a 4-3 or 3-4.

 

A base nickel.

 

I will be interested to see how they stock the front seven, especially LB.

 

I could see Shaq Thompson ba a good candidate for them in the second round.