Quote:QB over any position, always.
If you have a pro bowl level QB and a pro bowl level DE the QB is always the better player. And the results in games show it.
I dunno I would take a JJ Watt over Luck, because Watt is already a healthy HOF caliber player & Luck is a great QB but he hasnt played at HOF level at QB like Watt has played at DE....
Quote:I dunno I would take a JJ Watt over Luck, because Watt is already a healthy HOF caliber player & Luck is a great QB but he hasnt played at HOF level at QB like Watt has played at DE....
You wouldn't last as GM for very long.
QB>DE
Read the darn title!
Poll: Best player in AFC south is?
Not most valuable. Not most important. Not hardest to find. It could be a freaking kicker if he was playing his position at a historic level.
Best player in AFC south is? The answer is Watt. Please stop the non-sense.
Quote:Read the darn title!
Poll: Best player in AFC south is?
Not most valuable. Not most important. Not hardest to find. It could be a freaking kicker if he was playing his position at a historic level.
Best player in AFC south is? The answer is Watt. Please stop the non-sense.
Adam Vinatieri is the best player in the division!
Quote:Adam Vinatieri is the best player in the division!
That's actually a good point, and fair!!! Haha
Whose y'all's long snapper? lol
Haven't you all heard? Will Ta'ufo'ou is the best player.
Now, I said it was my opinion that Watt was not deserving of the MVP (and I still strongly believe that), but to say JJ Watt is not the best player in the AFC South would be foolish.
Andrew Luck is obviously a very close 2nd, for now, to me at least.
Who is the third best player? That's a question we could debate.
Quote:Now, I said it was my opinion that Watt was not deserving of the MVP (and I still strongly believe that), but to say JJ Watt is not the best player in the AFC South would be foolish.
Andrew Luck is obviously a very close 2nd, for now, to me at least.
Who is the third best player? That's a question we could debate.
LOL at this...
JJ Watt couldn't even get his team into the playoffs... Luck is headed to the AFC Championship...
Luck is hands down the best player in the AFCS... And he's gonna be the best player in this division until another elite QB can knock him off that perch.
Quote:LOL at this...
JJ Watt couldn't even get his team into the playoffs... Luck is headed to the AFC Championship...
Luck is hands down the best player in the AFCS... And he's gonna be the best player in this division until another elite QB can knock him off that perch.
luck is certainly moving up the ladder.
This is a good one... First thing that popped into my head before opening the thread was luck, but watt may very well may be the best athlete in the whole league.... Idk, i'd say its a coin flip... Both have good arguments.