Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Full Version: Edgar Bennet should be our OC. He's good, needs a shot.
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Pages: 1 2 3
Bennett is a Jacksonville native, played ball at FSU, Greenbay and Chicago as a tailback. He worked as runningback coach for GB for six years beginning in 2001. He was promoted in 2011 to WR coach and has developed arguably the best core group of Wrs in the league, facilitating the emergence of several low key players. His rise through the ranks isn't all that different from other coaches aside from the factor of time, but I believe that is more to do with lack of opportunities than coaching abilities. Mike McCarthy is extremely high on him, and he is well respected around the league. I think Bennett is a dark horse that should receive strong consideration due to the excellent job he has done in GB and how closely he works with the offensive coordinator, Tom Clements.

 

McCarthy had this to say back in 2011:  


I don't think that was the primary reason for the change, but coach Mike McCarthy said Bennett "jumped through the door" when he learned of the opportunity.


"Going back to his personal development, it definitely increases here," McCarthy said during a break at the NFL scouting combine. "I think Edgar Bennett is someone that will be looked at like a potential coordinator candidate in the future. It's like anything. You coach running backs, any position, it's easy to get into that box and stay in it. When you're not coaching the other parts of the offense, you know it but you don't know it."

 


"It's one thing to know the plays and know the adjustments. But when you're coaching every day, it's totally different. This a great opportunity for Edgar personally, but this isn't about personal opportunity. This is about what's best for our offense, and we're going to be better for it."

 

Bennett is a hardworker, flexible, and football saavy coach who understands the game and how to get the most out of his players. His core philosophies are physicality, verticality, explosiveness, and studying the "bests". Not being rigid in coaching I think is also a strength.

 

"A drop that may not register...we consider a drop," Cobb said. "That's how we view ourselves in our room. We want to be hard on ourselves. We're our biggest critics. I feel like there were a few balls I didn't have that I should have had."

Bennett studies other receivers himself. It's all part of his personal progression from Green Bay's 10th all-time leading rusher to running backs coach to wide receivers coach to — potentially — offensive coordinator somewhere someday. You can't limit yourself to your own receivers, Bennett says. Like Cobb, he broke down receivers across the league.

 

I hope Gus doesn't pull another "buddy" pick and hires someone because he knows them. As we all know offensive coordinator duty involves more than just calling plays. You are the head coach of the offense and need to know the strengths and weaknesses of all your players and how best to put them in the right position to succeed. I think that ultimately is why Jedd Fisch was a failure, and why I hope Bennett gets a shot. I think because of his years of coaching and involvement with Tom Clements he would be a great coach for Bortles, our backs, and WRs.


Sorry long post!

I still think they're gonna go big name for the OC. Someone who is well known. I have respect for this dude but it probably won't happen. If you think about all the WR's he's developed it's actually scary. Greg Jennings, James Jones, Jordy Nelson, Randall Cobb, & Davante Adams. 3 Pro bowlers and I bet down the road Adams will become one too.

Switching from one position group to another is not a promotion. What makes you think it is?

 

I don't understand why the Packers did that because he never played wide receiver.

 

What we need is someone who started his career as a quarterback coach and was promoted to offensive coordinator. Nothing against Edgar Bennett, but the most important thing for us now is a guy who is known for developing quarterbacks and basing the offensive playbook on what the quarterback can do. You get none of that from Bennett.

Quote:I still think they're gonna go big name for the OC. Someone who is well known. I have respect for this dude but it probably won't happen. If you think about all the WR's he's developed it's actually scary. Greg Jennings, James Jones, Jordy Nelson, Randall Cobb, & Davante Adams. 3 Pro bowlers and I bet down the road Adams will become one too.


The talent he's help develop on offense is scary. I hope we do not get suckered by the big names. They are usually underwhelming and overrated.
Interesting!

Quote:I still think they're gonna go big name for the OC. Someone who is well known. I have respect for this dude but it probably won't happen. If you think about all the WRs he's developed it's actually scary. Greg Jennings, James Jones, Jordy Nelson, Randall Cobb, & Davante Adams. 3 Pro bowlers and I bet down the road Adams will become one too.
 

Jarrett Boykin was good too when Randall Cobb was on IR last year. And don't forget Donald Driver.
Quote:Switching from one position group to another is not a promotion. What makes you think it is?


I don't understand why the Packers did that because he never played wide receiver.


What we need is someone who started his career as a quarterback coach and was promoted to offensive coordinator. Nothing against Edgar Bennett, but the most important thing for us now is a guy who is known for developing quarterbacks and basing the offensive playbook on what the quarterback can do. You get none of that from Bennett.
So the ability to coach one position group is predetermined by what position you played? You realize some coaches never played a lick of football? If you know football, you know football. Just because you played QB doesn't mean you're an expert at coaching Qbs. Coaching is an art form and not everyone is equipped to do it.
Quote:Switching from one position group to another is not a promotion. What makes you think it is?

 

I don't understand why the Packers did that because he never played wide receiver.

 

What we need is someone who started his career as a quarterback coach and was promoted to offensive coordinator. Nothing against Edgar Bennett, but the most important thing for us now is a guy who is known for developing quarterbacks and basing the offensive playbook on what the quarterback can do. You get none of that from Bennett.
JDub, it doenst really work that way.  Coaches bounce around successfully all over the place.  They arent players.

 

Why didn't you make your name MissJagsDiva or MissJagsDuval, or something so we could call you MJD?

Quote:So the ability to coach one position group is predetermined by what position you played? You realize some coaches never played a lick of football? If you know football, you know football.
Beat me to it.  Exactly.
Quote:JDub, it doesn't really work that way. Coaches bounce around successfully all over the place. They aren't player.

 

Why didn't you make your name MissJagsDiva or MissJagsDuval, or something so we could call you MJD?
 

MJD is at the bottom of Oakland's depth chart, everybody would get confused by the initials, and I am not a diva or Duval County resident.
Quote:So the ability to coach one position group is predetermined by what position you played? You realize some coaches never played a lick of football? If you know football, you know football. Just because you played QB doesn't mean you're an expert at coaching Qbs. Coaching is an art form and not everyone is equipped to do it.
 

You'd think from some of the twisted panty squad around here that there's something difficult about it.

 

Blake already has a QB coach that he says he likes, so I'm not worried about whether Bennett is known as some kind of QB guru, I'm more concerned about whether he has the knowledge and moxy to understand, react to, and gameplan offensive football at the coordinator level.

 

If he does then I don't see a problem with making him the guy.
Quote:MJD is at the bottom of Oakland's depth chart, everybody would get confused by the initials, and I am not a diva or Duval County resident.
Burned! Me.
Quote:So the ability to coach one position group is predetermined by what position you played? You realize some coaches never played a lick of football? If you know football, you know football. Just because you played QB doesn't mean you're an expert at coaching QBs. Coaching is an art form and not everyone is equipped to do it.
 

I know Edgar Bennett is a good wide receivers coach. He has done a good job developing them. But we need a guy who has proven his ability to develop quarterbacks and that is not a Bennett's resume.
MissJagsDynasty?

I do not understand why all these posts are being made under OC Candidates instead of new threads with the OC of choice as the title?  Seems sily waste of space for readers and commentors alike.

Quote:I know Edgar Bennett is a good wide receivers coach. He has done a good job developing them. But we need a guy who has proven his ability to develop quarterbacks and that is not a Bennett's resume.
Let the QB coach do his job JDub.
Quote:MissJagsDynasty?
MissBroncosFanatic?
Quote:You'd think from some of the twisted panty squad around here that there's something difficult about it.

 

Blake already has a QB coach that he says he likes, so I'm not worried about whether Bennett is known as some kind of QB guru. I'm more concerned about whether he has the knowledge and moxy to understand, react to, and gameplan offensive football at the coordinator level.

 

If he does then I don't see a problem with making him the guy.
 

Gus Bradley said he fired Jedd Fisch because of a different philosophy in how to develop Blake Bortles. That means he can't just rely on Frank Scelfo to improve at the quarterback position, but also needs an OC who is good at developing quarterbacks.
Quote:MissJagsDynasty?
 

There is no dynasty to talk about. I am not a Patriots fan, you know.
Quote:Gus Bradley said he fired Jedd Fisch because of a different philosophy in how to develop Blake Bortles. That means he can't just rely on Frank Scelfo to improve at the quarterback position, but also needs an OC who is good at developing quarterbacks.


I think that's key word for he wasn't really great as a coach. Like I said anybody can call plays.
Pages: 1 2 3