Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Thought this would be a neat way to pass time between blowout losses. Obviously I'd like to emphasize that as fans, we can only go by what we see on TV and that none of us are experts at evaluating talent. Just for fun.

I used the following scale (out of 100)


90+: Impact player

80's: Good starter

70's: Average starter

60's: Below average

50's: Street FA level

Anything under 50 is the cashier at 711 that played some high school football.


Henne- 65

Gerhart- 68

Ta'ufo'ou- 70

Shorts- 78

Hurns- 73

Lee- 70

Lewis- 75

Joeckel- 68

Beadles- 62

McClendon- 55

Linder- 65

Pasztor- 67


Red- 80

Marks- 84

Miller- 70

Clemons- 85

Hayes- 68

Poz- 85

Reynolds- 67

Ball- 78

Gratz- 75

Blackmon- 69

Guy- 65

Cyprien- 82

Prosinski- 3


Anger- 85

Scobee- 90

I actually own M15 and they rated us at 73. We will be dropping to 71 after the next game update. It's virtually impossible to win with them online against other people. Second worst team is the Redskins, but they're going to go up to 79-80 overall after Sunday.

Henne- 65
Gerhart- 60
Ta'ufo'ou- 65
Shorts- 75
Hurns- 75
Lee- 67
Lewis- 80
Joeckel- 70
Beadles- 65
McClendon- 50
Linder- 60
Pasztor- ?? hasnt played yet

Red- 75
Marks- 82
Miller- 70
Clemons- 78
Hayes- 65
Poz- 80
Reynolds- 65
Ball- 75
Gratz- 72
Blackmon- 67
Guy- 65
Cyprien- 80

Anger- 99
Scobee- 85