Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Of course it's my opinion, but I believe Boselli to be a top-3 OL of all-time. Jimmy was great. I just don't think he's as good as Boselli. 

 

Boselli, Smith, Taylor. 

 

Brunell was a decent QB, but I can't imagine what kind of stats Jimmy would've put up with Manning throwing to him in Indy, or in the new offense-centered NFL that favors passing stats. Randy Moss, Marvin Harrison, Torry Holt, Reggie Wayne, etc. etc.  all seemed to benefit from great QBs. Jimmy was screwed over there but still put up some amazing games and seasons. Had he been in a better offense, I think he would've easily broken 14,000 yards.

I would say it was long ding.

In this order, Taylor, Boselli, and JSmooth.  4th on the list would have to be "The Mangler", Greg Hunington.

Fred Taylor

Quote:Mark Brunell. Where's the love for the greatest Jaguar QB of all time?

Mark was the man for us but if you really step back and look at his stats, they weren't that great.

Tie between Fred Taylor and Boselli.

Fred

The better talent? Fred Taylor. The better player? Jimmy.

Quote:Mark was the man for us but if you really step back and look at his stats, they weren't that great.

 

They were great for this franchise, but not for nearly as long as his legend would indicate, and not great by NFL standards.

Greatest Jaguar ever Coughlin.  He started as the first head coach and though he had problems with the money side, the team was competitive.  I wonder had he stayed would the team had a SuperBowl appearance by now?

Fred is first. Smith would be second. Boseli was a Dominant Right Tackle( I know he played left Tackle but its hard to judge when our QB was Left Handed) where is the love for Leon Searcy the tackle that actually protected Brunels backside? Everyone talks about how Tony Dominated Bruce Smith in that bills game, but if you watch the game Tony did dominate him for the first part but then Bruce Smith moved to the other side and kept changing across the d-line. I think Tony was better then average and a probowl Tackle and his injuries took him out to soon so we will never know how good he would have been protecting a QBS backside. (if Tony got beat, Mark ran the other way so no sack.)

Quote:The better talent? Fred Taylor. The better player? Jimmy.

This

Quote:Fred is first. Smith would be second. Boseli was a Dominant Right Tackle( I know he played left Tackle but its hard to judge when our QB was Left Handed) where is the love for Leon Searcy the tackle that actually protected Brunels backside? Everyone talks about how Tony Dominated Bruce Smith in that bills game, but if you watch the game Tony did dominate him for the first part but then Bruce Smith moved to the other side and kept changing across the d-line. I think Tony was better then average and a probowl Tackle and his injuries took him out to soon so we will never know how good he would have been protecting a QBS backside. (if Tony got beat, Mark ran the other way so no sack.)

Tony was better than average. Got it.

Keenan McCardell.

Jimmy Smith's career went nowhere once McCardell went to Tampa Bay...

Where he had 2 TD receptions in the Super Bowl he helped win...

Quote:Keenan McCardell.

Jimmy Smith's career went nowhere once McCardell went to Tampa Bay...

Where he had 2 TD receptions in the Super Bowl he helped win...

Do you even know what you are talking about? Jimmy went over 1000 yards every year Keenan was gone except for 2003 in which he only played 12 games.

Quote:Keenan McCardell.

Jimmy Smith's career went nowhere once McCardell went to Tampa Bay...

Where he had 2 TD receptions in the Super Bowl he helped win...

LOL!!!

It's got to be James Stewart. He had that 5 TD game and since he left the Jaguars were never the same. Coincidence? I think not.

Quote:Do you even know what you are talking about? Jimmy went over 1000 yards every year Keenan was gone except for 2003 in which he only played 12 games.

Wow! Looks like you're right. Jimmy Smith averaged 1000 yards receiving in his final 4 years, without McCardell. I guess I just remember some things wrong.

Gotta go with Tony. If he had played longer, he could have gone down at the best OT in NFL history.

 

1. Tony Boselli

2. Jimmy Smith

3. Fred Taylor