Question: Is Jamies Winston already a better college QB than Tim Tebow?
Winston has already won as many Nat'l Championships as Tebow has as a starter-IN HIS FRESHMAN YEAR. Tebow was not a starter in his freshman year. Leak was the starter on that team.
Winston has already won the Heisman-in his FRESHMAN YEAR. Tebow didn't win until his sophomore year.
Winston QBd an undefeated team to win the National Championship. Tebow never QBd an undefeated team.
Winston led the Seminoles back from an 18 point deficit-largest in BCS history. Tebow didn't erase that big of a deficit, did he?
Even with this National championship game, he is already viewed as a more viable NFL prospect than Tebow.
Discuss
This is gonna be a fun thread to follow.. Should get a lot of laughs out of this one..
Yes.
And a better pro prospect than Tebow is now.
Quote:Question: Is Jamies Winston already a better college QB than Tim Tebow?
Winston has already won as many Nat'l Championships as Tebow has as a starter-IN HIS FRESHMAN YEAR. Tebow was not a starter in his freshman year. Leak was the starter on that team.
Winston has already won the Heisman-in his FRESHMAN YEAR. Tebow didn't win until his sophomore year.
Winston QBd an undefeated team to win the National Championship. Tebow never QBd an undefeated team.
Winston led the Seminoles back from an 18 point deficit-largest in BCS history. Tebow didn't erase that big of a deficit, did he?
Even with this National championship game, he is already viewed as a more viable NFL prospect than Tebow.
Discuss
Of course Winston is better. He's a carry-the-team-back-from-the-brink elite QB prospect.
Tebow was a fullback playing in a gimmick offense that was carried by the guys around him.
eh... we're a culture of accomplishments. Winston will need another title to match Tebow's two.
Besides, if Tebow had been playing for Auburn last night, I'd argue that they win the game.
Allow me to retort:
Quote:Question: Is Jamies Winston already a better college QB than Tim Tebow? False. It's unpossible. Advantage Gator-bows. Next statement.
Winston has already won as many Nat'l Championships as Tebow has as a starter-IN HIS FRESHMAN YEAR. Tebow was not a starter in his freshman year. Leak was the starter on that team. Florida was such a great team, that not even the almighty Tebow himself could start in his Freshman year. FSU stinks so bad, and at such a high level, that they are forced to start Freshmen.
Advantage Gator-bows. Next statement.
Winston has already won the Heisman-in his FRESHMAN YEAR. Tebow didn't win until his sophomore year. Tebow allowed Troy Smith to win the Heisman so as to not upset the sensitive sensibilities of the Ohio State fanbase that his Head Coach, the great Urban Meyer, would soon coach. Tebow is a team player and wanted Meyer to be comfortable when he decided to abandon the Florida football program, Winston is selfish since he did not want Manziel to win the trophy two years in a row.
Advantage Gator-bows. Next statement.
Winston QBd an undefeated team to win the National Championship. Tebow never QBd an undefeated team. See how much harder Tebow had to work to win a title? Tebow faced adversity, Tebow had to deal with losing, Tebow had to deal with having Percy Harvin on his team. Winston's trail was so easy, he even let his Defense score from time to time. Besides, without defeats there can be no teary-eyed emotional post game speech that gets plaque-fied and mounted on the wall. Advantage Gator-bows. Next statement.
Winston led the Seminoles back from an 18 point deficit-largest in BCS history. Tebow didn't erase that big of a deficit, did he? Tebow never played bad enough to face an 18 point deficit in the BCS title game, did he? Advantage Gator-bows. Next statement.
Even with this National championship game, he is already viewed as a more viable NFL prospect than Tebow. Blind, myopic, narrow minded thinkers think that, and cannot see the advantage of a professional Quarterback who posts a six for 22, zero touchdown, one interception game. Advantage Gator-bows. Next statement.
Discuss
I think we're done here.
Tebow would have performed better than Marshall?
Quote:Allow me to retort:
I think we're done here.
So what you're saying is Tebow = best thing since sliced bread?
Quote:eh... we're a culture of accomplishments. Winston will need another title to match Tebow's two.
Besides, if Tebow had been playing for Auburn last night, I'd argue that they win the game.
Tebow won a championship but was not the starting QB (Leak). So it's not like he was the starting QB on 2 championship teams.
Quote:So what you're saying is Tebow = best thing since sliced bread?
You're missing some details and you've glossed over my perfectly crafted, dominate grammar but yes; in a nutshell that's the way any good Gator-bow should view him.
Quote:You're missing some details and you've glossed over my perfectly crafted, dominate grammar but yes; in a nutshell that's the way any good Gator-bow should view him.
Tebow is so good....it's as if he thought up slicing the bread himself.
Quote:Question: Is Jamies Winston already a better college QB than Tim Tebow?
Winston has already won as many Nat'l Championships as Tebow has as a starter-IN HIS FRESHMAN YEAR. Tebow was not a starter in his freshman year. Leak was the starter on that team.
Winston has already won the Heisman-in his FRESHMAN YEAR. Tebow didn't win until his sophomore year.
Winston QBd an undefeated team to win the National Championship. Tebow never QBd an undefeated team.
Winston led the Seminoles back from an 18 point deficit-largest in BCS history. Tebow didn't erase that big of a deficit, did he?
Even with this National championship game, he is already viewed as a more viable NFL prospect than Tebow.
Discuss
Winston is better and None of those awards and who did what and when matters.
Tebow is Christian Laettner. Winston is Magic Johnson.
Quote:Tebow is Christian Laettner. Winston is Magic Johnson.
So what you're saying is that Winston has AIDS?
Quote:So what you're saying is that Winston has AIDS?
Dont forget Winston also has more rape accusations as well!
Quote:So what you're saying is that Winston has AIDS?
Magic Johnson doesn't have AIDS. Ignorant.
Quote:Question: Is Jamies Winston already a better college QB than Tim Tebow?
Winston has already won as many Nat'l Championships as Tebow has as a starter-IN HIS FRESHMAN YEAR. Tebow was not a starter in his freshman year. Leak was the starter on that team.
Winston has already won the Heisman-in his FRESHMAN YEAR. Tebow didn't win until his sophomore year.
Winston QBd an undefeated team to win the National Championship. Tebow never QBd an undefeated team.
Winston led the Seminoles back from an 18 point deficit-largest in BCS history. Tebow didn't erase that big of a deficit, did he?
Even with this National championship game, he is already viewed as a more viable NFL prospect than Tebow.
Discuss
Based on this dumb post, you are also implying that Winston is the best ever QB in college history so I'm not certain why you limited your post to a comparison of Tebow only.
Also, please note that Tebow played a role in winning the championship during his true Freshman year. Winston is a Redshirt Freshman
I don't care for either but I dont remember Tebow lookinh like utter [BLEEP] during a title game.
Quote:Based on this dumb post, you are also implying that Winston is the best ever QB in college history so I'm not certain why you limited your post to a comparison of Tebow only.
Also, please note that Tebow played a role in winning the championship during his true Freshman year. Winston is a Redshirt Freshman
Yes Tebow played a role...as a glorified short yardage back....a bit player.
His first year as a starter-which was his Sophomore year, he (Tebow) didn't win anything.
Winston won the National Title his first year as a starter-a redshirt Freshman.