Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Let "The Debate" begin.

Brady x3

Henne

uncle rico

Where's the option for Ricky Stanzi?

Quote:Where's the option for Ricky Stanzi?

If Stanzi were an option everybody would pick Stanzi and there would be no point in having a poll.

Quote:If Stanzi were an option everybody would pick Stanzi and there would be no point in having a poll.

It would be like having Johnny Cash as an option; who would pick anything else?

Peyton

Brady

Brady

 

Peyton is the better player, but Brady is the better leader and has played on better teams.

I'll take Shane Falco over those two bums. 

 

 

"Pain heals.  Chicks dig scars.  Glory... lasts forever."

Pizza.

Manning Manning Manning . . . because I am a Broncos fan rooting for him Sunday.

Manning

Brady

Manning

 

Now if this were the playoffs, I'd take Brady.  But I'll take Peyton Manning in a warm weather super bowl any day over Brady.  Brady's great.  But he's not Peyton's level.  Sure he won 3 super bowls.  But with a team Matt Cassel took 11-5.

Quote:uncle rico

 

/thread

i like the other debate better, who is worse, who you want if you wanted the #1 pick and who you want in a better team, gabbert or henne 

Quote:Manning

Brady

Manning

 

Now if this were the playoffs, I'd take Brady.  But I'll take Peyton Manning in a warm weather super bowl any day over Brady.  Brady's great.  But he's not Peyton's level.  Sure he won 3 super bowls.  But with a team Matt Cassel took 11-5.

 

 

The reason why I didn't pick Denver to reach the Super Bowl this season is because Peyton Manning probably won't be on top of his game if the weather is adverse in a playoff game.    The elements took their toll on him against the Ravens in the playoffs last season,  as that game went on.

 

Tonight,  the weather is expected to cold and windy in Foxboro,  MA.   It will be interesting to see how Manning does in this game,   especially with the injury related question marks the Patriots have on Defense.   My gut feeling is the Patriots will find a way to win this game. 

Quote:i like the other debate better, who is worse, who you want if you wanted the #1 pick and who you want in a better team, gabbert or henne 

 

Chad Henne doesn't have enough ability to be anything close to a long term solution as a starter . But when combining the ability that Henne has and his high caliber leadership skills,   it wouldn't surprise me if he helps lead the Jaguars to a couple of more wins this season.   If the hope is to secure the # 1 pick,  Henne could prove costly if enough of his teammates improve in the coming games.

Manning

Brady

Manning.


I think manning is the better QB. But Brady has more rings so the second question goes to Brady easy. That kills me to say that because I don't like Brady at all. I chose manning for the third as well. I know manning hasn't been all that great post season and again, Brady is so I guess it should go the other way. But I'm going to go with the better QB which I feel is manning. Not liking Brady only played a factor in the last question.

Brady always showed up to the Super Bowl with a better defense.  I kinda like the guy, but I hate the Patriots.  And their obnoxious fans. 

 

And the entire city of Boston, actually.

 

But I digress.  If the game was played this year, I'd probably take Phillip Rivers over either one.  He's in better shape.  Otherwise, I'd go with Manning.

It's a wash.....I'm watching another Brady comeback......now Peyton comes roaring back.....31-31. 3 min left....Brady ball

Brady.....3 and out.......Manning with 1:34 left on his own 33.....will he capitalize?