Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

How do you currently rank them?

Knee
Shoulder
Shoulder
Nerve Damage

1 Bortles
2 luck
3 mary
4 watson

(11-06-2018, 08:32 AM)Jagwired Wrote: [ -> ]1 Bortles
2 luck
3 mary
4 watson

Come on.. Luck is better than Mariota

(11-06-2018, 02:09 AM)TurndownforWatt Wrote: [ -> ]How do you currently rank them?

1. Luck/Watson
3. Mariotta/Bortles/Kessler

25. Gabbert

(11-06-2018, 02:09 AM)TurndownforWatt Wrote: [ -> ]How do you currently rank them?

1.  Luck.  Second place isn't even close.
2.  Watson.
T3.  Mariota/Bortles

1. Luck








2. Watson
3. Bortles
4. Mariota

---

I'd say collectively the AFC east has the worst QB play in the NFL. After that it's probably us and the NFC east tied for a close second.

LOL at this thread

Bortles sucks boys

the only thing that is for sure is that bortles is the worst of the 4... by far

Let me bring some fair rankings to the table...

1. BOAT- that's my QB yo- the PEOPLES QB
2. Watson- Texans got a nice one
3.Luck- Don't trust that shoulder yet, but looks damn good
4. Mariota- a lot tougher and better than people give him credit for
5. Bottles- some say AJ CANN still has concussion symptoms

Mary
Bortles
Luck
VY ... i mean watson

1. Watson hes already a champ from college football,and has Texans on thier way to winning the Super Bowl-, plus thier defense is healthy. Defense wins champtionships when you can score.

2. Luck -hes looked great since returning from his injury

3. Mariotia is a double theart QB  


4. Bortles- if object of game was to have great charther Bortles would be a all pro,but its not. Bortles is to much of a inconsistists QB. up,and down,up and down. Rarley has serveal games in a row were he plays up up up up up weekly

1. Watson hes already a champ from college football,and has Texans on thier way to winning the Super Bowl-, plus thier defense is healthy. Defense wins champtionships when you can score.

2. Luck -hes looked great since returning from his injury

3. Mariotia is a double theart QB  


4. Bortles- if object of game was to have great charther Bortles would be a all pro,but its not. Bortles is to much of a inconsistists QB. up,and down,up and down. Rarley has serveal games in a row were he plays up up up up up weekly

Currently I rank them.

1. Luck - Proven QB with experience in the NFL.
2. Watson - College Winner turned NFL starter. He's not up there with the Lucks, Rogers, Brady's of the world, but it's VERY early in his career.
3. Mariota - Often injured, but when healthy and on fire, he is a dual threat nightmare.
4. Bortles - Up and Down seems to describe him best. Flashes skills, but inconsistency dictates that he cannot be trusted.

Can't we rip them into shreds, and Frankenstein each one's best attributes into one HOF QB?

It's really kind of tough to rank them.  All have good/bad traits.  Perhaps...

Luck
Bortles/Mariotta/Watson

(11-06-2018, 07:17 AM)flsprtsgod Wrote: [ -> ]Knee
Shoulder
Shoulder
Nerve Damage

That is [BLEEP] funny right there......

Luck
Watson
Bortles/Mariota in a tie

I don't think Bortles will be starting next year unless something amazing happens, and Mariota is slowly playing himself out of a job. Luck is somehow still legit, and Watson looks the part at least half the time.

Category - Attempts - Comp - Comp % - Yds passing - TD's passing - QB rating - Interception % 


1st in Div - Luck         Luck     Mariota       Watson           Luck           Watson          Luck
2nd in Di - Bortles     Watson    Luck           Luck            Watson          Luck           Watson
3rd in Di  - Watson    Bortles   Watson       Bortles           Bortles        Mariota         Mariota
4th in Di  - Mariota    Mariota   Bortles       Mariota          Mariota        Bortles          Bortles

Watson
Luck
whoever Jags get to replace Bortles
whoever tacks get to replace Mary