Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Welcome to the dead offseason. Let's assume all 32 teams were putting together teams from all the players who have ever played for them, who would be on your Jaguars team? You can also add 10 additional PS players if you'd like.


A little different from the All-Times Jag team in that you can kind of project the rookies and FAs and how they would be going forward. Mine would be:


HC : Tom Coughlin


QB - M.Brunell, B.Bortles

RB - F.Taylor, M.Drew (KR), T.Yeldon

FB - G.Jones, M.Owens (ST)

WR - J.Smith, A.Hurns

WR - A.Robinson, K.McCardell, C.Shorts

TE - J.Thomas, M.Lewis, K.Brady

LT - T.Boselli, E.Monroe

LG - V.Manuwai, B.Coleman

C - B.Meester, B.Linder

RG - C.Naeole, A.Cann

RT - L.Searcy, M.Williams

LEO - T.Brackens, D.Fowler

DT - M.Stroud, S.Marks

NT - J.Henderson, T.Knighton

DE - G.Walker, M.Jackson, C.Simmons

WLB - M.Peterson, T.Smith

MLB - P.Poz, M.Jack

OTTO - K.Hardy, D.Smith, B.Paup

CB - J.Ramsey, A.Beasley, B.Williams

FS - T.Gipson, R.Nelson

SS - D.Darius, D.Grant

CB - R.Mathis, D.House,

K - J.Scobee

P - B.Barker

LS - J.Zelenka


PS

QB - D.Garrard

RB - T.Banks

WR - M.Jones (don't judge)

TE - P.Mitchell

C - M.Cheever

DE - P.Spicer

DE - J.Smeenge

LB - A.Ayodele

CB - F.Bryant

S - M.McCree


Suspended - J.Blackmon (lol)


*Used the Gus defensive scheme because I feel like a lot of these guys would fit the system well:

• Brackens would thrive as a LEO

• Stroud and Henderson with Gary Walker at the big end would eat up the run game.

• Darius at the Chancellor spot would be insane.

• Paup was a bust under Coughlin but would've probably played better if he could've just rushed the passer


Who do you guys got?

I need to see the new players in action first.


 

I'm surprised you have Terrance Knighton over Roy Miller. Not that I necessarily disagree, but with Oesher's consistent gushing over Miller I doubt many feel this way.

Quote:I need to see the new players in action first.


I'm surprised you have Terrance Knighton over Roy Miller. Not that I necessarily disagree, but with Oesher's consistent gushing over Miller I doubt many feel this way.

Yeah I am projecting a bit and also assuming these guys hit or play at their peak. I think Knighton's peak (when he cared enough to be in shape) was a bit higher than Roy's.


This list also shows you where the Jags have been kind of weak in their history like CB (outside of Mathis, Beasley, and maybe Ramsey), edge rusher (outside of Brackens and hopefully Fowler), WR (outside of Jimmy, Keenan, and the Allens), etc.

Shorts over Hurns is where i stopped reading.

Quote:Shorts over Hurns is where i stopped reading.

You should probably learn to read then lol

Beast

Lol Shorts shouldn't be on this list. He's garbage.


Reggie Williams is better than Shorts.

You should assign each current and historical player a dollar amount and set a cap. See who makes the consensus best team.

Fowler has no business on the list.

Quote:Fowler has no business on the list.

lol I said projection...


Anyways let's see your list, bruh...

Mike Pete played Mlb

Quote:lol I said projection...


Anyways let's see your list, bruh...

LOL you said projected for rookies and FA bruh. Fowler is neither.

 

I got over making silly lists when I was 14.

QB - Bortles, Brunell, Garrard

RB- Taylor, Jones-Drew, Yeldon

FB- G. Jones

WR- Robinson, Smith, Hurns, McCardell, M. Jones

TE- Thomas, Lewis, Brady

LT- Boselli, Joeckel

LG-Manuwai, Cann

C- Meester, Wisniewski

RG- Linder, Naeole

RT- Searcy, Mo Williams


RE- Brackens, Heyward

DT- Stroud, Henderson, Malik, Marks

NT- Miller

LE- Walker, Simmons, Odrick

OLB- D. Smith, T. Smith

MLB- Mike Pete, Poz

OLB- Hardy, Paup

CB- Mathis, Beasley, House, Amukamara, Bryant

FS- Gipson, Nelson

SS- Darius, Grant


K- Scobee

P- Hanson

LS- Cain

Quote:Mike Pete played Mlb

this, Mike Pete at MLB and D Smith at WLB

Deon Grant was a good free safety in his heyday.

Mike Hollis

Dieon Figures

Micky Washington

Chris Hudson

Ty Hallock

Maston

Lake

Nickerson

Bryant

Bortles over Brunell for me. Give me upside over a slightly higher floor.


I think Jalen is a great prospect but hard to put him as a starter when he's never played a snap.