Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

I've been offered Lynch and Dez for J. Hill and Maclin. Accept?

Depends on ur depth. If u currently have enough playmakers to win u games while u wait foe Lynch and Bryant to get healthy, then yeaj, sure.. But if not, u gotta win now. Dont blow ur season by acquiring players via trade that cant make an impact for several weeks.


Dez is an uphrade from Maclin but at this point, Im not sure that Lynch carries better fantasy value than Hill.


All that said, I would probably hold off.


p.s. i just traded away Ryan Mathews, Demarco Murray and Landry for Doug Martin, Tyler Eifert and Martavis Bryant- wudda ya think?

Picked up devonta Freeman when tevin Coleman went down and never looked back. He's been good for 35+ points the past two weeks.

I think you got the edge there. Ryan + Demarco are equal to 1, and I like the upside of Eifert/Bryant compared to Landry

Would you counter with Hill for Lynch straight up? Reports are optimistic about Lynch. Not sure if Hawks OL that bad or Lions D that good

Quote:I think you got the edge there. Ryan + Demarco are equal to 1, and I like the upside of Eifert/Bryant compared to Landry

Thats exactly how i saw it. The philly backs equal 1 rb and Bryant prolly comes on stronger mid-late season tt han Landry will.


And yeah, i think thats a good counter offer. Dez will be out a while

I probably wouldn't Hill will be better as the weather worsens and Maclin is consistent which you need in the regular season.  Lynch is hurt and that offensive line has been awful and Dez is out till the vast majority of the fantasy season is over.  Keep what you have.

He's sweetening the deal now.

Lynch/Dez/Broncos DST for Hill/Maclin

Sounds good to me. Reports are Lynch looking healthy but hamstrings can be deceiving, Dez back week 7 but Romo out longer and Broncos D looks nasty good so far.

Think I'm going to sleep on it and shop Hill around more

Quote:i just traded away Ryan Mathews, Demarco Murray and Landry for Doug Martin, Tyler Eifert and Martavis Bryant- wudda ya think?

Id say losing landry is the only real loss there and getting 3 quality players at 3 different position is good for roster flexibility  I like it

 

Quote:Picked up devonta Freeman when tevin Coleman went down and never looked back. He's been good for 35+ points the past two weeks.

He has played well, but before Tevin went down I thought he was the better back.  It will be interesting when Tevin is healthy again how they rotate the two.

Quote:He's sweetening the deal now.

Lynch/Dez/Broncos DST for Hill/Maclin

Sounds good to me. Reports are Lynch looking healthy but hamstrings can be deceiving, Dez back week 7, and Broncos D looks nasty good so far.

I still wouldn't do it.  Dez won't be back that soon and if he is he will be a shell.  Broncos are a good D however..


vs pack, vs colts, vs pats, vs steelers, vs bengels, vs chargers and a bye week.  The easier offenses is what they have feasted on so far the rest of the schedule is tougher

Hill is conflicting and unless I want to tank the next two games or so, I can't deal Maclin with Steve Smith sidelined. Two good games and two noshows for Hill, hasn't put up much yardage but scoring TDs is nice. If he wasn't splitting with Gio or fumbling twice in week 2, it'd be easier.

Quote:Hill is conflicting and unless I want to tank the next two games or so, I can't deal Maclin with Steve Smith sidelined. Two good games and two noshows for Hill, hasn't put up much yardage but scoring TDs is nice. If he wasn't splitting with Gio or fumbling twice in week 2, it'd be easier.

I have hill too.  Ride it out Gio could go down for injury at any time and that offensive line is really good.  As the weather gets colder and starts effecting games Hill gets better, its one of the big reasons he was so good the end of last season.  haha Actually I have Steve Smith too 

I'd say thats a steal for you and I'd jump the gun on that if I were you.


I'm pretty decent at FF seeing how in the past three years ive came in 1st or 2nd. (2012, 1st. 2013, 2nd. 2014, 2nd{by .44 points}.


Take the deal.

Seahawks line looked sooo bad I don't think I would deal for Lynch

Dez/Broncos D' = the same points Hill n Maclin would make.


The Chief's are in trouble this year, and Cincinnati's backfield could change from week to week..between Hill n Bernard.


Lynch is the better pick, no back up to take any carries away, plus like others were saying about Hill..i guess they forgot Lynch plays better in the cold also.

Quote:Dez/Broncos D' = the same points Hill n Maclin would make.


The Chief's are in trouble this year, and Cincinnati's backfield could change from week to week..between Hill n Bernard.


Lynch is the better pick, no back up to take any carries away, plus like others were saying about Hill..i guess they forgot Lynch plays better in the cold also.

my point with lynch is you are picking an old RB that currently has an injury behind an offensive line that has been garbage over a young stud running back running behind one of the better Olines in football.  

bold prediction:  broncos d will only put up the points its been putting up 2 more times.

Quote:I'm pretty decent at FF seeing how in the past three years ive came in 1st or 2nd. (2012, 1st. 2013, 2nd. 2014, 2nd{by .44 points}.

 

Thats one of those stats that doesn't really say anything.  We don't know what size league or how competitive it is or the intelligence of the overall league.  it could just be you and a bunch of other casual fans that don't really know what they are doing and just pick all the players on the team they root for.


or if you play five leagues every year and only place in 1 one of them

Quote:I've been offered Lynch and Dez for J. Hill and Maclin. Accept?

As said previously, if you can cope without them for the next 3 games I'd take it.

Is Rawls still available to handcuff Lynch? If so I'd take it and stash Rawls for emergencies. If not I'd be cautious. I usually do well streaming defenses, and Lynch's hammy could pull a Marqise Lee

Quote:I've been offered Lynch and Dez for J. Hill and Maclin. Accept?

 

Yeah I would accept.


I mean Maclin has been a bit of a disapointment in my opinion.