Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Full Version: Tyrod Taylor or Derek Carr?
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Which should I get? I can get Taylor off waivers and Carr in a trade for Larry Donnell (maybe throw in Allen Robinson or Golden Tate for TJ Yeldon or Joseph Randle in return also).

Id say Taylor. He has more weapons and an over all better team than the raiders IMO. Carr does have cooper and Crabtree has looked better than I expected however I still dont believe in them overall. Plus no trade needed.

well thing is getting yeldon or randle is appealing to me and i have jordan cameron as my starting TE. i would get both but idk about having 4 qbs on my roster (i already have bortles and big ben but he is hurt which is why i'm looking for another qb). i guess my dilemma is that ordinarily i would take taylor straight up but because i want one of the backs as well the framework of the trade interests me.

If you do have more of a need for the TE or RB then you may as well take up the trade. I just personally believe Taylor is better option at QB, however you seem to be fine at QB really so it falls back on the other options lol.

I'd rather have Taylor