Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Aaron.

is it really close who has more rings...hate to say it because don't like team, coach, or player but Brady

If everything depends on winning the next game, im taking Brady without a second thought.

 

Picking a franchise QB, ill take Rodgers since hes much younger.

Quote:If everything depends on winning the next game, im taking Brady without a second thought.

 

Picking a franchise QB, ill take Rodgers since hes much younger.

 

 

I'll agree with this.

If you're of the mindset that Brady is the GOAT.

Then your answer can't be anything but Brady, because he is still in the NFL. And you deem him the greatest ever.

 

That being said.... Rodgers has no asterisks.

Brady, IMO he plays better against the elite defenses

Over the last 4 years Brady has been to the conference championship every year, while Rodgers has been to one.


If you have to pick a QB to win a divisional playoff game I don't see how it is even close.

Quote:Over the last 4 years Brady has been to the conference championship every year, while Rodgers has been to one.


If you have to pick a QB to win a divisional playoff game I don't see how it is even close.

Well, Rodgers isn't a habitual cheater, so...

Quote:Well, Rodgers isn't a habitual cheater, so...

And the NFC has been stronger for the past few seasons.

Quote:And the NFC has been stronger for the past few seasons.

 

Rodgers lost to Eli Manning, Kappernick x 2, and Wilson over the last 4 years.  Doesn't the best QB in the league win at least half of these games?

 

Those teams are no better than the Broncos, Ravens, and Steelers teams of the last few years, and the super bowls are a wash.

 

Rodger's is a great QB, but he has to win a lot more playoff games before he can be considered more dependable than Brady.

Uhhhh you guys are all forgetting about GOAT Matt 'We're gonna score' Hasslebeck

its been Aaron for at least 3 years now,

Blake Bortles is the best, drinks his teal koolaid like a good follower...