Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Full Version: Good not Great MLB players
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Pages: 1 2 3 4
i definitely agree with Dykstra.

 

Does Barry Bonds count?  He'll never sniff the HOF

Anyone mention Larry Walker (Rockies) yet?

 

Johnny Damon was good with the Red Sox.

Quote:Some 80's pitchers. Frank Viola, Orel Hershiser, Mark Langston, Mike Scott, Brett Saberhagen, Dennis Martinez, Dave Stewart.
 

I'm not certain if it was because of Monday Night Baseball or not but Hersheiser, Saberhagen, Ron Guidry, and Steve Carlton are very visible in my memories; even more so than Nolan Ryan, Gooden, and Clemons (as I look back at the top pitchers website)
You could probably throw alot of solid relievers in this list.

 

John Franco, Tom Henke, Jeff Reardon.

Quote:i definitely agree with Dykstra.


Does Barry Bonds count? He'll never sniff the HOF


Well since you're mentioning Phillies I'll flip-flop and mention:


Rennie Stennet

Dave Cash

Bill Madlock
Another former Phillie, Gary Matthews.

 

Somehow my first baseball glove as a kid was a Gary Matthews glove. Probably a hand me down or from Goodwill.

Quote:Well since you're mentioning Phillies I'll flip-flop and mention:


Rennie Stennet

Dave Cash

Bill Madlock
 

Cash & Stennett were both solid and consistent.


Getting Mad Dog (Madlock) from the Giants was a steal ..... 


06-28-1979

Traded by San Francisco Giants with Lenny Randle and Dave Roberts to Pittsburgh Pirates in exchange for Ed Whitson, Fred Breining and Al Holland (June 28, 1979).

 

 


Anyone remember U.L. Washington (KC Royals) playing with a toothpick in his mouth all of the time.

Michael Young


Alfonso Soriano
Quote:Anyone remember U.L. Washington (KC Royals) playing with a toothpick in his mouth all of the time.


Yes. Along with Frank White, the DP combo for the Royals when the Phils beat them in the World Series in 80. I think Willie Wilson struck out 100 times in that World Series. Actually only 13 but it was a record at the time.
And the above reminds me of another.


Amos Otis
One player still active who is a very good, extremely versatile player is Martin Prado.

Quote:And the above reminds me of another.


Amos Otis
 

 One of the worst trades the Mets ever made was trading a young Amos Otis for Joe Foy. 
Dave Kingman


Jack Clark


Rob Deer


Cecil Fielder


Gorman Thomas


Sensing a theme here?
Quote:Dave Kingman


Jack Clark


Rob Deer


Cecil Fielder


Gorman Thomas


Sensing a theme here?
 

Recently retired Adam Dunn comes to mind when reflecting on your list.   Any of these players was a prime candidate to lead the league in HRs and Strikeouts.  
Quote:Recently retired Adam Dunn comes to mind when reflecting on your list. Any of these players was a prime candidate to lead the league in HRs and Strikeouts.

I don't think Clark belongs in that group. You could certainly add Mark Reynolds to that group and he may have a leg up on them. Hell, he had 200+ strikeouts for three straight years.  He's a dominant force on this list.

Quote:I don't think Clark belongs in that group. You could certainly add Mark Reynolds to that group and he may have a leg up on them. Hell, he had 200+ strikeouts for three straight years.  He's a dominant force on this list.
 

 

  I definitely know where you are coming from regarding Jack Clark.   He's probably at or near the borderline of the group,

 

  Overall,  these type of players are enjoyable to watch because of their ability to hit moonshots.   But on the other side of the coin,   they are prone to long slumps,  which often lead to extended slumps for the overall team they are on.   Especially,  if they considered everyday starters or close to that.
Quote:Dave Kingman


Jack Clark


Rob Deer


Cecil Fielder


Gorman Thomas


Sensing a theme here?
 

Pete Incaviglia may also fit on there.
Quote:Pete Incaviglia may also fit on there.


Guy always reminded me of a beer swilling softball player...and I've seen plenty. Smile
Ill just put a two names. 

Vernon Wells

Jorge Posada
Pages: 1 2 3 4