NFL prospect comparison game.  Name 2 prospects to come out, the next person answers who they feel is the better prospect and then that person names 2 more and so on.   You can explain your reason on why you think one prospect is better than the other if you want or you can just choose and say the next 2 prospects.  The players can be from any draft you choose.

 

 

 

I'll go first

 

 

 

Amari Cooper vs. Justin Blackmon

 

 

---

NFL prospect comparison game.  Name 2 prospects to come out, the next person answers who they feel is the better prospect and then that person names 2 more and so on.   You can explain your reason on why you think one prospect is better than the other if you want or you can just choose and say the next 2 prospects.  The players can be from any draft you choose.

 

 

 

I'll go first

 

 

 

Amari Cooper vs. Justin Blackmon

 

Blackmon (on the football field only) > Cooper

 

Next:

 

Kevin White vs. Sammy Watkins

---

"I am only an average man, but by George, I work harder at it than the average man." - Teddy Roosevelt

Blackmon (on the football field only) > Cooper

 

Next:

 

Kevin White vs. Sammy Watkins

I would go with Sammy Watkins as the better prospect.  Sammy was great all 3 years in college and I believe the number 1 recruit coming out of High School, also had over 1200 yrds and 12 TDs his freshman year.  Although White did have a great year this year but I would give the edge to Watkins.

 

 

Todd Gurley vs Darren McFadden 

---

Gurley


Mariota vs Kaepernick

---

Mariota

 

Winston vs Bortles

---

Mariota


Winston vs Bortles

Winston. Though had Bortles come out this year, I think he'd be better.


Beasley vs Von Miller

---

IT WAS ALWAYS THE JAGS

Mariota


Winston vs Bortles

The other one was first.

---

Thought this thread was gonna be about Grier vs Harris. Spring game numbers were close but if you watched the game greir is definitely the better QB.

---

Coughlin when asked if winning will be a focus: "What the hell else is there? This is nice and dandy, but winning is what all this is about."

Winston. Though had Bortles come out this year, I think he'd be better.


Beasley vs Von Miller

Von Miller


Marcell Dareus VS Leonard Williams

---

Von Miller


Marcell Dareus VS Leonard Williams

Williams, more athletic, more versatility.


Melvin Gordon III vs Le'veon Bell.

---

Williams, more athletic, more versatility.


Melvin Gordon III vs Le'veon Bell.

Gordon. Very close though.


Marquise Lee v Nelson Agholor

---

Crab Cakes and Football! That's what Jacksonville does!

Gordon. Very close though.


Marquise Lee v Nelson Agholor

Lee


Heath Miller vs. Maxx Williams

---

Lee


Heath Miller vs. Maxx Williams

Williams. Elite pass catcher.


Mariota vs Tannehill

---

Crab Cakes and Football! That's what Jacksonville does!

Williams. Elite pass catcher.


Mariota vs Tannehill

Tannehill. He has gotten better and better each year and Mariota is an unknown with high likelihood to bust.

 

Winston vs. Manziel

---

Lmao this thread should just stop

---

"Get Better Everyday"

Tannehill. He has gotten better and better each year and Mariota is an unknown with high likelihood to bust.

 

Winston vs. Manziel

Not really fair to compare Tannehill now to Mariota now, you compare them coming out of college, not a big fan of either but I would go Mariota.

 

But

 

Odell Beckam vs donvontae parker since one was the 3rd WR picked and the other is the 3rd rated

---

<B><FONT color=cyan>Jags this is your year</FONT></B>

Tannehill. He has gotten better and better each year and Mariota is an unknown with high likelihood to bust.


Winston vs. Manziel

Manziel


Kenny Vaccaro vs Landon Collins

---

Not really fair to compare Tannehill now to Mariota now, you compare them coming out of college, not a big fan of either but I would go Mariota.


But


Odell Beckam vs donvontae parker since one was the 3rd WR picked and the other is the 3rd rated

You are right, this is based on them coming out of college.


I like Parker better, woild of never thought Beckham would be so great


Vaccaro vs Collins

---

Vaccaro. More range and heavier hitter.


Khalil Mack v Fowler

---

Crab Cakes and Football! That's what Jacksonville does!

Vaccaro. More range and heavier hitter.


Khalil Mack v Fowler

Mack by just a little

 

Mike Evans vs. Kevin White

---