Wrote a bit about Samaje Perine for this upcoming draft.
https://tyrantscouting.com/2017/01/27/sa...ng-report/
Been wanting to try write something to do with football for ages so I gave it a try.
Let me know what you think. All comments welcome good and bad. Especially the bad ones actually.
Nicely written, and I enjoyed the use of gifs to back up your claims.
I guess I just don't like running backs that aren't home run threats. Perine looks very solid and strong, but I personally hope we pass on him in the first 3-4 rounds.
Quote:Nicely written, and I enjoyed the use of gifs to back up your claims.
I guess I just don't like running backs that aren't home run threats. Perine looks very solid and strong, but I personally hope we pass on him in the first 3-4 rounds.
Thank you sir. Do you think I need to use more gifs for the "Areas of concern" bit?
Its a fair point as he's petty much the same as a Ivory. We need a big play guy, havn't had one at RB since MJD.
Quote:Thank you sir. Do you think I need to use more gifs for the "Areas of concern" bit?
Its a fair point as he's petty much the same as a Ivory. We need a big play guy, havn't had one at RB since MJD.
I think adding more gifs would be beneficial, but only a few more. I've seen reports where there are 50 gifs which is too much.
Personally, this is how I view running backs. RBs at this level can all pretty much run with decent blocking. What can they do above the Xs and Os? Will they be able to take a 2 yard loss and turn it into a 50 yard touchdown sometimes? If the safety takes a bad angle, does the RB score a touchdown, or does he just gain an extra 12 yards?
This is why I would rather have Mixon over Perine.
Perine has intriguing size, but I wish he was more of a quick twitch player. NATRONE Means was like 245 and was extremely quick as well. I think Natrone Means would be the 2nd or 3rd best RB if he was coming out this year.
Everyone would rather have Mixon over Perine on the field. Just that little KO'd a girl on video thing...
Quote:I think adding more gifs would be beneficial, but only a few more. I've seen reports where there are 50 gifs which is too much.
Personally, this is how I view running backs. RBs at this level can all pretty much run with decent blocking. What can they do above the Xs and Os? Will they be able to take a 2 yard loss and turn it into a 50 yard touchdown sometimes? If the safety takes a bad angle, does the RB score a touchdown, or does he just gain an extra 12 yards?
This is why I would rather have Mixon over Perine.
Perine has intriguing size, but I wish he was more of a quick twitch player. NATRONE Means was like 245 and was extremely quick as well. I think Natrone Means would be the 2nd or 3rd best RB if he was coming out this year.
Cheers, added a few more.
I get that but think Perine goes above and beyond the Xs and Os in his own way. You can design any kind of defense you want but if the running back can break a tackle or two it changes everything.
Because I had to watch Perine so much I ended up watching a ton of Mixon too. Mixon is amazing. Can do it all.
It's a good write up, I like it!
I've read a few reports on Perine and one thing I've noticed is that a number seem to repeat the line that he hasn't got great hands (sometimes this like appears to have been copied and pasted word-for-word from another review).
I think you are more correct when you say he simply hasn't had that many opportunities. But I've seen nothing in what we have seen to suggest he can't catch.
And as for the top speed, I'm not sure that's a big deal. You are drafting him to break tackles and be a goal-line threat primarily. If he runs through a bunch of players and gets a big gain here or there then great.
Bigger worry for me is that he might not find it so easy to trample over NFL players.
If he can, then he could be our LeGarrett Blount - he's not got the greatest top-speed, but he's been effective enough.
Quote:It's a good write up, I like it!
I've read a few reports on Perine and one thing I've noticed is that a number seem to repeat the line that he hasn't got great hands (sometimes this like appears to have been copied and pasted word-for-word from another review).
I think you are more correct when you say he simply hasn't had that many opportunities. But I've seen nothing in what we have seen to suggest he can't catch.
And as for the top speed, I'm not sure that's a big deal. You are drafting him to break tackles and be a goal-line threat primarily. If he runs through a bunch of players and gets a big gain here or there then great.
Bigger worry for me is that he might not find it so easy to trample over NFL players.
If he can, then he could be our LeGarrett Blount - he's not got the greatest top-speed, but he's been effective enough.
Cheers Andy.
I watched 8 of his games as that's all I could find, he caught 4 passes in total and looked natural doing so. What I noticed was that the QB rarely if ever looked at him as a checkdown and a lot of the time Perine didn't offer himself up as a receiver even when he wasn't pass blocking. Don't know if that's by design or not.
He plays a lot like Spencer Ware for the Chiefs. Great at breaking tackles and runs really hard.
Good write up. The only thing I disagree on is the speed/big play ability. I think Perine has plenty of big play ability. Sometimes that can't necessarily be measured by a 40 time, but I do think he's faster than a 4.6 though. In the past 3 years, he has long runs of 66, 72 and 66 yards. He also averaged runs of 6.0 and 6.5 yards per carry, before this season where he really split time in the backfield with Mixon. His numbers dipped to a still very respectable 5.4 yards per carry. I think he is a really good mix of power and big play ability. The only thing that concerns me about him is the same thing that concerns me about Fournette, injuries.
Quote:Good write up. The only thing I disagree on is the speed/big play ability. I think Perine has plenty of big play ability. Sometimes that can't necessarily be measured by a 40 time, but I do think he's faster than a 4.6 though. In the past 3 years, he has long runs of 66, 72 and 66 yards. He also averaged runs of 6.0 and 6.5 yards per carry, before this season where he really split time in the backfield with Mixon. His numbers dipped to a still very respectable 5.4 yards per carry. I think he is a really good mix of power and big play ability. The only thing that concerns me about him is the same thing that concerns me about Fournette, injuries.
Cheers sir.
He's fast just not that fast compared to a lot of starting NFL running backs. He's gets caught from behind a lot and doesn't have that extra gear that some guys do to pull away from a defense. His bread and butter is breaking tackles and tough running so its not a big deal but its definitely an area that he's weak at.
You're right though I'd a say 4.55 in the dash is probably more realistic than a 4.6
Quote:Cheers sir.
He's fast just not that fast compared to a lot of starting NFL running backs. He's gets caught from behind a lot and doesn't have that extra gear that some guys do to pull away from a defense. His bread and butter is breaking tackles and tough running so its not a big deal but its definitely an area that he's weak at.
You're right though I'd a say 4.55 in the dash is probably more realistic than a 4.6
Whether it's by speed or by power, he has the ability to break long runs and that's something we've lacked since Mojo left. He's one of the handful of RB's in this draft that I'd love to see us pick. I think a 4.55 is more along the lines of his abilty. I know a lot of NFL RB's who turned out to be stars, who ran in that range.
Quote:Whether it's by speed or by power, he has the ability to break long runs and that's something we've lacked since Mojo left. He's one of the handful of RB's in this draft that I'd love to see us pick. I think a 4.55 is more along the lines of his abilty. I know a lot of NFL RB's who turned out to be stars, who ran in that range.
Yeah I'd love him with our 3rd round pick.
Reminds me of Spencer Ware a lot. Ware ran a 4.6 on his pro day but looks faster than Perine in general. He should get really high marks in everything else.
That's the thing though, Freeman would smoke Perine in a race.
Quote:Yeah I'd love him with our 3rd round pick.
Reminds me of Spencer Ware a lot. Ware ran a 4.6 on his pro day but looks faster than Perine in general. He should get really high marks in everything else.
That's the thing though, Freeman would smoke Perine in a race.
Devonta Freeman ran a 4.58. Le'Veon Bell ran a 4.6.
Quote:Devonta Freeman ran a 4.58. Le'Veon Bell ran a 4.6.
Yup. Freeman is faster than Perine, Bell ran 230 but is at around 220 now and is much faster/agile.
Perine might be able to cut 10 pounds , gain some more speed and still be very good.
Great job JackCity, well written!
I dig it! Not too long winded and I like the gif use to support your writing points.
Quote:Yup. Freeman is faster than Perine, Bell ran 230 but is at around 220 now and is much faster/agile.
Perine might be able to cut 10 pounds , gain some more speed and still be very good.
A lot of players lose some weight before the Combine. We'll just have to wait and see what he comes in at. It doesn't matter who we draft at RB though unless we address the O-Line as well and I'd still like to add a blocking FB. I think that could help immensely.
Quote:Great job JackCity, well written!
Thanking you.
Quote:I dig it! Not too long winded and I like the gif use to support your writing points.
Yeah the gifs are a pain in the [BLEEP] but the article is almost pointless without them.
The Perine hype train is beginning. Looking forward to his combine