Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Quote:lol, that actually is a funny thought.

I would have Frank do his Morgan Freeman.  That outta be the right speed for Peyton Manning on an end around.  Also, a mortuary tone for when he gets hit.

Quote:The consensus top QBs in the NFL are Peyton Manning, Drew Brees, Aaron Rogers, and Tom Brady.

 

Russell Wilson's record against them?

 

6-0

We beat the Texans twice last year.  Does that make Andre Branch better than JJ Watt?

Quote:We beat the Texans twice last year.  Does that make Andre Branch better than JJ Watt?

It would if they handled the ball on every snap.

Quote:It would if they handled the ball on every snap.

So, according to your logic, when we beat the Browns, that made Brad Meester better than Alex Mack.

Quote:So, according to your logic, when we beat the Browns, that made Brad Meester better than Alex Mack.

Maybe on that day.

Quote:Maybe on that day.

Why don't you try watching a game before you analyze it?

Quote:Why don't you try watching a game before you analyze it?

Why are you taking a shot at me?  I'm just using the Socratic method.

Quote:Why are you taking a shot at me?  I'm just using the Socratic method.

Excellent.  I note your conclusion transitioned from an unconditional absolute to a statistical possibility in a single post.  At what point while pondering my question did you realize your assumption was based on a false premise?

Quote:So, according to your logic, when we beat the Browns, that made Brad Meester better than Alex Mack.

 

 

Quote:Maybe on that day.

 

LOL.  

 

QB vs QB stats are totally meaningless.  When Russell threw for 103 yards and no TD vs the Saints, was he better than Drew Brees? 

 

:no:

Quote:LOL.  

 

QB vs QB stats are totally meaningless.  When Russell threw for 103 yards and no TD vs the Saints, was he better than Drew Brees? 

 

:no:

Amazing how many people don't realize there are 10 other guys out on the field with the quarterback.  Plus another whole group called the defense.

Quote:LOL.


QB vs QB stats are totally meaningless. When Russell threw for 103 yards and no TD vs the Saints, was he better than Drew Brees?


:no:

Geno Smith beat Drew Bree's last year too.

Quote:Geno Smith beat Drew Bree's last year too.

Exactly. Geno may turn out to be a good QB, but he wasn't better than Brees in that game - and he probably will never be.

 

It's just a silly "stat."   (quotations because it's really not a statistic  -- more a novelty noting)

Quote:LOL.  

 

QB vs QB stats are totally meaningless.  When Russell threw for 103 yards and no TD vs the Saints, was he better than Drew Brees? 

 

:no:

Well, he did read his book twice.  Which is probably more times than Drew Brees did with ghost writers these days.

Quote:Exactly. Geno may turn out to be a good QB, but he wasn't better than Brees in that game - and he probably will never be.

 

It's just a silly "stat."   (quotations because it's really not a statistic  -- more a novelty noting)

Like a pitchers W-L record, it's a team stat and the supporting cast is a huge factor.  ERA is a much better indication of effectiveness.