Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Full Version: Frozen Wind Turbines in Texas Expose Major Flaw in Renewable Energy
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9
(02-21-2021, 08:23 PM)mikesez Wrote: [ -> ]
(02-20-2021, 08:09 PM)flsprtsgod Wrote: [ -> ]I expect politicians to [BLEEP] over their constituents for their own benefit.  I've never been disappointed.

You see what you want to see.

And you can do what you wanna do.
Here is an interesting opinion piece on the failure of the electric grid in Texas. 
  
According to this expert, in spite of all the finger-pointing, it wasn't deregulation that was at fault, and it wasn't use of renewable energy that was at fault.  It was simply a failure to winterize their system.  



Texas goes it alone on electric power. That's actually a good thing

Quote:
It is not Texas' independent grid design that caused this electricity crisis. Nor is it deregulation, which is simply a market structure that gives customers more choice in electricity plans, similarly to how you pick a cell phone service provider. For more than 20 years, Texas' deregulated market has kept energy prices low, and sparked incredible growth in wind energy.


Our system's power failure wasn't caused by frozen windmills as our governor falsely claimed on Fox News, or Texas' inability to pull electricity from other states -- so-called interconnectivity. Texas wind is indeed a remarkable success story -- it provides about 40% of our total energy capacity and is a direct result of our deregulated market. But we don't rely heavily on Texas wind this time of year.

[font=CNN,]The overwhelming majority of last week's generation failures were due to failures in natural gas power plants.[/font]

End Quote
(02-24-2021, 06:08 AM)The Real Marty Wrote: [ -> ]Here is an interesting opinion piece on the failure of the electric grid in Texas. 
  
According to this expert, in spite of all the finger-pointing, it wasn't deregulation that was at fault, and it wasn't use of renewable energy that was at fault.  It was simply a failure to winterize their system.  



Texas goes it alone on electric power. That's actually a good thing

Quote:
It is not Texas' independent grid design that caused this electricity crisis. Nor is it deregulation, which is simply a market structure that gives customers more choice in electricity plans, similarly to how you pick a cell phone service provider. For more than 20 years, Texas' deregulated market has kept energy prices low, and sparked incredible growth in wind energy.


Our system's power failure wasn't caused by frozen windmills as our governor falsely claimed on Fox News, or Texas' inability to pull electricity from other states -- so-called interconnectivity. Texas wind is indeed a remarkable success story -- it provides about 40% of our total energy capacity and is a direct result of our deregulated market. But we don't rely heavily on Texas wind this time of year.

[font=CNN,]The overwhelming majority of last week's generation failures were due to failures in natural gas power plants.[/font]

End Quote

That author is being too specific with the word deregulation.
He's right that the competitive market Texas created is not the problem.
And he's right when he says the problem was failure to winterize.
But both of those are regulatory issues.
Regulations force winterization all the time. Like most states, Texas enforces a frost line depth in its building code. This was a blind spot for them.
(02-24-2021, 08:17 AM)mikesez Wrote: [ -> ]
(02-24-2021, 06:08 AM)The Real Marty Wrote: [ -> ]Here is an interesting opinion piece on the failure of the electric grid in Texas. 
  
According to this expert, in spite of all the finger-pointing, it wasn't deregulation that was at fault, and it wasn't use of renewable energy that was at fault.  It was simply a failure to winterize their system.  



Texas goes it alone on electric power. That's actually a good thing

Quote:
It is not Texas' independent grid design that caused this electricity crisis. Nor is it deregulation, which is simply a market structure that gives customers more choice in electricity plans, similarly to how you pick a cell phone service provider. For more than 20 years, Texas' deregulated market has kept energy prices low, and sparked incredible growth in wind energy.


Our system's power failure wasn't caused by frozen windmills as our governor falsely claimed on Fox News, or Texas' inability to pull electricity from other states -- so-called interconnectivity. Texas wind is indeed a remarkable success story -- it provides about 40% of our total energy capacity and is a direct result of our deregulated market. But we don't rely heavily on Texas wind this time of year.

[font=CNN,]The overwhelming majority of last week's generation failures were due to failures in natural gas power plants.[/font]

End Quote

That author is being too specific with the word deregulation.
He's right that the competitive market Texas created is not the problem.
And he's right when he says the problem was failure to winterize.
But both of those are regulatory issues.
Regulations force winterization all the time. Like most states, Texas enforces a frost line depth in its building code. This was a blind spot for them.

Correct. You can have a competitive market with participants that are regulated to maintain some baseline of preparedness which would have staved off this problem.
It was pretty much clear that winterization was the problem. This is why I think it's foolish to come down so hard on any one group with regards to this issue. It was a freak storm. It sucks. I'm sure people will winterize moving forward, but it's never been needed. It's hard to function if you have to account for EVERY possible calamity.
Pages: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9