(02-21-2022, 08:16 AM)flgatorsandjags Wrote: [ -> ]Let's see yalls top 5 QB rankings
Based on QB talent alone, not thinking about stats, records, or rosters...
Best QBs right now, on a roster...
Aaron Rodgers
Patrick Mahomes
Josh Allen
Russell Wilson
T5 Joey B and Herbert
I think Stafford has been wildy underrated but I think recency bias may be going into some rankings/lists since the Rams just won the SB. Arod is the best QB talent wise imo. Patrick Mahomes is very similar in talent. Josh Allen has come along very well and his arm strength and running abilities are premo. DangeRuss is still a very very good QB and cant believe hes an after thought because the Hawks roster has become not very good. I cheat a bit here putting Joe Burrow and Herbert tied for 5th but the two young QBs are very very talented and with improved rosters around them are likely to be the top tier guys in years to come.
Brady would have made my list if he hadn't retired
(03-01-2022, 06:51 PM)Kane Wrote: [ -> ] (02-21-2022, 08:16 AM)flgatorsandjags Wrote: [ -> ]Let's see yalls top 5 QB rankings
Based on QB talent alone, not thinking about stats, records, or rosters...
Best QBs right now, on a roster...
Aaron Rodgers
Patrick Mahomes
Josh Allen
Russell Wilson
T5 Joey B and Herbert
I think Stafford has been wildy underrated but I think recency bias may be going into some rankings/lists since the Rams just won the SB. Arod is the best QB talent wise imo. Patrick Mahomes is very similar in talent. Josh Allen has come along very well and his arm strength and running abilities are premo. DangeRuss is still a very very good QB and cant believe hes an after thought because the Hawks roster has become not very good. I cheat a bit here putting Joe Burrow and Herbert tied for 5th but the two young QBs are very very talented and with improved rosters around them are likely to be the top tier guys in years to come.
Brady would have made my list if he hadn't retired
A reasonable list.
As I said before...in terms of being most physically gifted, I would give the nod to Allen, I think his combination of physical tools (strongest arm, straight line speed, size) checks all the boxes.
But he has to win to be considered up with Mahomes and Rodgers. Unfortunately for him (and fortunately for me)m he hasn't gotten Buffahole over the hump, and until he does, I can't put him on top of any overall best QB list.