Jacksonville Jaguars Fan Forums

Full Version: Honest question would you rather have...
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Pages: 1 2 3 4
#1 ARob & AHurns or Reggie Williams & Matt Jones. I know people might think this is crazy but Reggie & Matt were the better tandem.
     As bad as Reggie and Matt were at least they caught the ball. Reggie had 10 TD in a season and he was terrible. (Remeber the 80 yard TD pass from Quin Gray to
     Reggie in NO?)
 
#2 Would you rather have Blake Bortles or David Garrard? Between the two who will ultimately have the better career?
 
   David 18TD 3 Int = Playoffs ( And I know we had Fred and Maurice)
Once the blueprint was out on Garrard he could do nothing more than check down to the RB
Quote:Once the blueprint was out on Garrard he could do nothing more than check down to the RB
 

Agreed...but he didn't cost his team games with stupid pick 6's
Quote:Agreed...but he didn't cost his team games with stupid pick 6's
you make a different thread every single minute so do us a favor and go ban yourself.
Quote:Agreed...but he didn't cost his team games with stupid pick 6's


That's because Garrard wouldn't throw to the WRs. Would you honestly take captain checkdown over Bortles. Everyone knew Garrards ceiling. We dont know Bortles.
Well I was never a fan of Matt Jones so I easily go Arob and Hurns with that one.

 

I liked David and everything but I still feel as if Blake has the chance to be better than him, given Davids career really wasnt much more than a one hit wonder season in which like you stated we had a great running game.

Quote:you make a different thread every single minute so do us a favor and go ban yourself.
 

Truth hurts don't it leopold but you keep drinking the Gus bradley Kool-Aid I'll sit back and watch us go 4-12 again
Quote:That's because Garrard wouldn't throw to the WRs. Would you honestly take captain checkdown over Bortles. Everyone knew Garrards ceiling. We dont know Bortles.
 

I understand Garrard was captain check down but I'd rather have that than a Qb that loses us games too. How many killer INT do you remember David  throwing to cost us games?

In 1 year and 1 game Blake already has 4-5 backbreakers
I remember that time Reggie Williams broke into a dance celebration for making a block. He was awesome
Quote:Truth hurts don't it leopold but you keep drinking the Gus bradley Kool-Aid I'll sit back and watch us go 4-12 again


You da man
Quote:I understand Garrard was captain check down but I'd rather have that than a Qb that loses us games too. How many killer INT do you remember David throwing to cost us games?

In 1 year and 1 game Blake already has 4-5 backbreakers


How about him singlehandedly losing a game for the Jaguars at Tennessee in 2006? Costing the team a playoff spot. How about throwing an INT against Washington in overtime in 2010 when the team was still in playoff contention? Should I keep going?
I'd take Hurn and Robinson.  Reggie was bad, and Matt Jones' YAC equaled his height falling forward upon catching the ball. 

 

To date, I would take Garrard. But, I think in another year, the easy answer will be Blake. 

Quote:you make a different thread every single minute so do us a favor and go ban yourself.


Easily one of the top five worst posters around.
Quote:Agreed...but he didn't cost his team games with stupid pick 6's


Herp derp

<a class="bbc_url" href='http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/recap?gameId=261217010'>http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/recap?gameId=261217010</a>
Quote:Herp derp

<a class="bbc_url" href='http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/recap?gameId=261217010'>http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/recap?gameId=261217010</a>


Sure was a nice try though huh?
Quote:Herp derp

<a class="bbc_url" href='http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/recap?gameId=261217010'>http://sports.espn.go.com/nfl/recap?gameId=261217010</a>
Wow lol... there is being wrong, then there is this.
Walters needs more opportoonies. He catches everything
David Garrard in his "prime" I would take again.

Blake has a chance of being a bust. Hope he isn't obviously but he's going to have to overcome a lot.


WR wise I think I'll go with Arob and Hurns, but it's closer than I would like it to be.
Matt Jones was actually kind of awesome. He looked half asleep and tried to catch every pass with one hand. And Reggie was a darn good blocker.
Quote: 

<div>#2 Would you rather have Blake Bortles or David Garrard? Between the two who will ultimately have the better career?
 
   David 18TD 3 Int = Playoffs ( And I know we had Fred and Maurice)
 

</div>
 

David Garrard was drafted in 2002. He didn't have a good season until 2007, and was mediocre after that. Others have pointed out the meltdown in 2006. I also remember a game against the tacks in 2004 where he couldn't hit the broad side of a barn in spite of the tacks being down to their 3rd string CBs. T
he Jags barely lost and missed the playoffs that year by one game.

 

If Bortles still isn't any good in 2019, then you can say Garrard was better. I'll wait.

Pages: 1 2 3 4