I do. I'll post the grades when I get home tonight if anyone likes. No link obviously though.

Thanks!! I pick it up every year when it releases because I open alot of football card draft products (I collect rookie autos). Helps to figure out the lower tier guys.

---

Nobody doubts he is a great prospect!! Just the lovefest is creepy, along with the fact you tear down every other prospect and whine if anyone dares come between you and your boy toy.

Took awhile for you to come around, I just happen to like good qbs. Anything wrong with that?

---

Took awhile for you to come around, I just happen to like good qbs. Anything wrong with that?

Never once said he was a bad qb! Most of your doubters are in the same boat, you live and breath him (again, its creepy). Anyone in their right mind, is keeping an open mind.

---

Never once said he was a bad qb! Most of your doubters are in the same boat, you live and breath him (again, its creepy). Anyone in their right mind, is keeping an open mind.

My mind is open, but I haven't seen anyone who could sway it. If McCarron stepped up against Oklahoma, I would be liking him a lot. I don't like he came up small when they needed him the most and then proceeded to blame freshman for why the team didn't win it all. A QB NEVER, EVER puts blame for a lose on anyone else but himself, even if he is in the right.

---

My mind is open, but I haven't seen anyone who could sway it. If McCarron stepped up against Oklahoma, I would be liking him a lot. I don't like he came up small when they needed him the most and then proceeded to blame freshman for why the team didn't win it all. A QB NEVER, EVER puts blame for a lose on anyone else but himself, even if he is in the right.

even being a bama fan, I put no more than a third round on AJ. I would put a first on the big three qbs, but to say taking Teddy third would make us an instant contender is far from the truth.

---

even being a bama fan, I put no more than a third round on AJ. I would put a first on the big three qbs, but to say taking Teddy third would make us an instant contender is far from the truth.

 

Really?  Why just third round?  Even Bama media is saying he's not your typical Bama QB.

 

Is it the chip on the shoulder?  Too much talent around him?  I wouldn't be surprised if we were looking at him with our second rounder.  Sounds as if he made a good impression at the combine by participating, and had a good Pro Day, too.  I share the opinion of those who think he's overlooked.

 

And speaking of overlooked, is there a chance Norwood sneaks up boards, or is at least a later value pick?

---

"You do your own thing in your own time. You should be proud."

Really?  Why just third round?  Even Bama media is saying he's not your typical Bama QB.

 

Is it the chip on the shoulder?  Too much talent around him?  I wouldn't be surprised if we were looking at him with our second rounder.  Sounds as if he made a good impression at the combine by participating, and had a good Pro Day, too.  I share the opinion of those who think he's overlooked.

 

And speaking of overlooked, is there a chance Norwood sneaks up boards, or is at least a later value pick?

value pick right now, AJ took more on than any qb I've seen come through in all my years as a tide fan and didnt miss a beat. Guess I missed the part where he blamed everyone else like wiseman said.

---

I dont know if i want to take McCarron in the second round but at the same time i think he will be gone by the time we pick in the third..

---

:thanks: Extra Life 2016 is 11/05/16 :thanks:

value pick right now, AJ took more on than any qb I've seen come through in all my years as a tide fan and didnt miss a beat. Guess I missed the part where he blamed everyone else like wiseman said.

 

He's probably referring to this: http://collegefootballtalk.nbcsports.com...t-success/

 

I really don't see much wrong with what he said, other than it was said at all.

 

Obviously, the older players felt the younger ones had/have a sense of entitlement from their early taste of winning.  Combine that with not having the experience of playing in and winning championships like the veterans have, and it's not hard to understand that sentiment.  If you weren't around to experience the hard work it took to bring home the hardware, then it's very understandable how young, highly touted recruits playing on a highly regarded team might not realize what it takes to win a game that they probably thought wasn't as much a challenge as they expected.

---

"You do your own thing in your own time. You should be proud."

I can't see McCarron being anything more than a backup or spot starter

---

I can't see McCarron being anything more than a backup or spot starter

funny, seems to be a broken record from tht Teddy fan club

---

funny, seems to be a broken record from tht Teddy fan club

Why so defensive? I never mentioned Teddy.

---

I can't see McCarron being anything more than a backup or spot starter

 

Few (ever) have a resume like his.  That alone earns him a shot.

---

"You do your own thing in your own time. You should be proud."

Why so defensive? I never mentioned Teddy.

So it was a different kfl that said passing on him would be a mistake, let's hope jags don't make that mistake?

---

So it was a different kfl that said passing on him would be a mistake, let's hope jags don't make that mistake?

That post had nothing to do with McCarron what so ever. Just because I like Teddy as a prospect doesn't mean I bash all other prospects. I get that there are some that go over board about certain prospects such as Teddy or Johnny Football but I'm not one of them.


If you want to read one of my posts about Teddy and lump me into a fanboy so be it but at least read my other posts where I also said I would be more than happy with Clowney, Mack, Watkins and even Bortles.

---

Thanks!! I pick it up every year when it releases because I open alot of football card draft products (I collect rookie autos). Helps to figure out the lower tier guys.

Ok Mr. Atburg here we go,


2011 QBs:


Gabbert 6.40

Locker 5.97

Newton 5.85

Stanzi 5.55

Kaep 5.551

Ponder 5.39

Dalton 5.25

Mallet 5.24


For anyone not familiar with his grading scale:


9.00 - once in a lifetime prospect

8.00-8.99 - perennial all pro

7.50-7.99 - future all pro

7.00-7.49 - should become pro bowler

6.50-6.99 - first rounder, possible pro bowler

6.00-6.49 - should become quality starter

5.50-5.99 - chance to become quality player

5.10-5.49 - better than average chance to make NFL roster

---

That post had nothing to do with McCarron what so ever. Just because I like Teddy as a prospect doesn't mean I bash all other prospects. I get that there are some that go over board about certain prospects such as Teddy or Johnny Football but I'm not one of them.


If you want to read one of my posts about Teddy and lump me into a fanboy so be it but at least read my other posts where I also said I would be more than happy with Clowney, Mack, Watkins and even Bortles.

Well i'm saying it AJ McCarron stinks 

---

Well i'm saying it AJ McCarron stinks 

PleaseplaceacommabetweenitandAJotherwiseitisjustarunningsentancethatdoesnotmakesenseanothermemberofthebridgewaterlovefestwhocontinuestoprovehimselfasnothingmorethana12yearoldtroll. That should keep you busy the rest of the day!

---

Ok Mr. Atburg here we go,


2011 QBs:


Gabbert 6.40

Locker 5.97

Newton 5.85

Stanzi 5.55

Kaep 5.551

Ponder 5.39

Dalton 5.25

Mallet 5.24


For anyone not familiar with his grading scale:


9.00 - once in a lifetime prospect

8.00-8.99 - perennial all pro

7.50-7.99 - future all pro

7.00-7.49 - should become pro bowler

6.50-6.99 - first rounder, possible pro bowler

6.00-6.49 - should become quality starter

5.50-5.99 - chance to become quality player

5.10-5.49 - better than average chance to make NFL roster

Thanks! I notice those who wanted link went silent.

---

That post had nothing to do with McCarron what so ever. Just because I like Teddy as a prospect doesn't mean I bash all other prospects. I get that there are some that go over board about certain prospects such as Teddy or Johnny Football but I'm not one of them.


If you want to read one of my posts about Teddy and lump me into a fanboy so be it but at least read my other posts where I also said I would be more than happy with Clowney, Mack, Watkins and even Bortles.

Sorry, my bad.

---