Would you trade the #1 and #33 picks for Matthew Stafford and Calvin Johnson?

---

Would you trade the #1 and #33 picks for Matthew Stafford and Calvin Johnson?

 

No. Just because I don't like Stafford at all and as dominant as CJ is, our receiving corp isn't exactly a weakness on the team.

 

Matt Ryan and a good pass rusher? Maybe.

---

TEST

Shaun King is pretty crazy either way.

 

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GTKLlffTaQk

 

That is the draftbreakdown footage of last nights game. Even with the overthrown/int and interception he still looked good. I don't think people realize he is rarely ever going to have RG3/Petty/Geno/Manziel like numbers in a college game due to the type of offense the Cardinals play.

 

8:05 is the most impressive throw of all IMO. 

---

Rutgers is a good team. For all you SEC lovers, you do realize they beat Arkansas, right?

 

Cool. So? Arkansas is trash.

 

An average, at best, Rutgers team beat a bad Arkansas team and I'm suppose to be impressed?

---

Only 10 more games to suffer through! Imagine what Blackmon would look like with Bridgewater throwing him the ball!

---

LEONARD FOURNETTE FAN CLUB PRESIDENT. I WAS BEHIND HIM WHEN YOU ALL SAID HE WAS BRANDON JACOBS. QUIT HATING ON THE JAGUARS. GUS IS GONE. COUGHLIN HAS RESTORED ORDER. FOURNETTE IS FRED TAYLOR. DONT BELIEVE ME JUST WATCH.

I'd personally like to see him take his favorite QB in the first and trade back into the third with his extra mid/late picks.


- but if he does get a king's ransom and still thinks there's a franchise QB to be had in the 2nd round.... well it would be tough to argue with all those picks in year 2 of a rebuild.

Ideal situation if we trade:


If we trade down hopefully we would still be able to stay in the top 5 (like the Rams) and still be able to draft a QB (Boyd, Mariotta, Metenburger).

---

"Before you criticize a man, walk a mile in his shoes. That way, if he gets angry, he's a mile away and barefoot."

8:05 is the most impressive throw of all IMO.

There are so many plays in this game that Henne/Gabbert can never make.


First time I've seen all the throws from this game. A couple head scratchers for sure, but otherwise some throws and plays he makes are awesome and plays we have never seen here in Jax

---

Shock the world

Yeah, a couple of missed throws but overall very solid showing by Teddy.  The pocket presence and delivering the ball under pressure is superb.

---

<FONT face="Comic Sans MS" size=3><B><FONT face=Verdana color=#ff6600 size=4></FONT></B></FONT>

teddy teddy teddy

---

cuz mr. coleman says so

At least the steelers won yesterday!

---

Shock the world

Would you trade the #1 and #33 picks for Matthew Stafford and Calvin Johnson?

 

#1 and #33 for an inconsistent QB and the best receiver in football?  Nope.  No deal.  Those picks are way too valuable, especially in this upcoming draft.  We can get a franchise quarterback with #1 and either an anchor interior lineman who will be a staple on our offensive line for the next decade or a capable running back to replace MJD with #33.

 

Plus, while Megatron would be an enticing luxury, we already have a good receiver in Shorts and an ascending star in Blackmon.

---

#1 and #33 for an inconsistent QB and the best receiver in football?  Nope.  No deal.  Those picks are way too valuable, especially in this upcoming draft.  We can get a franchise quarterback with #1 and either an anchor interior lineman who will be a staple on our offensive line for the next decade or a capable running back to replace MJD with #33.

 

Plus, while Megatron would be an enticing luxury, we already have a good receiver in Shorts and an ascending star in Blackmon.

 

So pretend knowing what we know about Calvin and Stafford, and they entered the NFL draft this year at this age, where do you think they are drafted?

 

I think Calvin gets drafted top 5 and Stafford top 20.

---

So pretend knowing what we know about Calvin and Stafford, and they entered the NFL draft this year at this age, where do you think they are drafted?

 

I think Calvin gets drafted top 5 and Stafford top 20.

 

Megatron would be a top five pick, but still not the number one overall pick.

 

Stafford would probably go late first-early second, knowing what we know right now.  Knowing what we know now, Stafford would probably grade out out similarly to Zach Mettenberger, which would be that early second round range.  He's a capable QB, but wildly inconsistent and I've always questioned his football IQ.  I think he'll be in Detroit for a couple more seasons, then head elsewhere either by his choice or via trade.

 

I think if a team was offered Brett Hundley or current Matthew Stafford, they take Hundley 9 times out of 10.  That's just my opinion, though.

 

Give me Teddy Bridgewater and ASJ (who could fall to #33) over Stafford and Megatron.  Plus, the former pair are 6-7 years younger.

---

I guess I don't agree with you. I think that Calvin is the most talented WR to ever play the position. He is in his prime. He is proven. He has 6+ more years of dominance. I think that is worth a #1 pick. There are too many question marks and busts in the NFL draft to pass up on an elite player like Calvin Johnson.

---

I guess I don't agree with you. I think that Calvin is the most talented WR to ever play the position. He is in his prime. He is proven. He has 6+ more years of dominance. I think that is worth a #1 pick. There are too many question marks and busts in the NFL draft to pass up on an elite player like Calvin Johnson.

 

And he's still a luxury pick.  Amazingly talented player.  But we're not at the point where we're contending for a Super Bowl.  You aren't getting a better player at that pick -- but WR is a luxury.

---

I was wrong about Trent Baalke. 

I guess I don't agree with you. I think that Calvin is the most talented WR to ever play the position. He is in his prime. He is proven. He has 6+ more years of dominance. I think that is worth a #1 pick. There are too many question marks and busts in the NFL draft to pass up on an elite player like Calvin Johnson.

Franchise QB > Calvin Johnson. All day.

---

Franchise QB > Calvin Johnson. All day.

 

Which is why my trade involved a franchise QB, too.

---

And he's still a luxury pick.  Amazingly talented player.  But we're not at the point where we're contending for a Super Bowl.  You aren't getting a better player at that pick -- but WR is a luxury.

 

You don't think that if we traded pick #1 and #33 for Stafford and Calvin, shored up the interior OLine with the rest of the draft, signed a couple veterans on defense, we would be contenders? I do...

---

Which is why my trade involved a franchise QB, too.

I don't consider Stafford a franchise QB. Too inconsistent.

---

I don't consider Stafford a franchise QB. Too inconsistent.

 

Um, if Flacco is considered a franchise QB, then Stafford is for dang sure a franchise QB.

---