Top 5 in the NFL right now.

Definitely. Look for the MVP hype to start at the rate he is producing.

---

Where were you lot last week...


Plus Hilton was the star


Oh and the Indy defence for bailing luck out twice at the end of the game after he couldn't finish it

---

Where were you lot last week...

Plus Hilton was the star

Oh and the Indy defence for bailing luck out twice at the end of the game after he couldn't finish it

Last week he tore up Baltimore for 312 yds and 2TDs.

---

OK to the top 5 brigade. Is he better than;


Manning Rodgers Rivers Romo Brady Brees Wilson?


Who's he knocking out I'm intrigued


Forgot Big Ben and Dalton

---

OK to the top 5 brigade. Is he better than;

Manning Rodgers Rivers Romo Brady Brees Wilson?

Who's he knocking out I'm intrigued

This year? Wilson, Brees, and Brady. He has outplayed all of them.

---

OK to the top 5 brigade. Is he better than;


Manning Rodgers Rivers Romo Brady Brees Wilson?


Who's he knocking out I'm intrigued


Forgot Big Ben and Dalton

 

If we're just talking this year, he's definitely better than Brady, Brees, & Wilson. Ben & Dalton aren't even close.

---

So your rankings change week to week? Wow you just decided 3 Superbowl champs aren't in the top 5 based off 5 games...


Homer much?

---

So your rankings change week to week? Wow you just decided 3 Superbowl champs aren't in the top 5 based off 4 games...


Homer much?

 

If you really think Brady is playing better than Luck THIS YEAR, you're the homer, not me.

 

EDIT: OF COURSE, if you look at the entire career it's Brady. He's played longer, not even close.

---

If you really think Brady is playing better than Luck THIS YEAR, you're the homer, not me.

I didn't say this year. I said top 5 qbs...


Only Indy fans invent small windows to overrate luck.


Indy are 1-2 outside the useless AFC south

---

So your rankings change week to week? Wow you just decided 3 Superbowl champs aren't in the top 5 based off 5 games...

Homer much?

What the hell. Just winning a SB in previous seasons guarantees you nothing when a new season starts. At this point Luck is playing better than those guys.

---

It's hilarious that Luck throws for 350+ yards, 3 touchdowns and you're trying to say he didn't have a good game.

 

THAT'S when you know you're one of the best.

---

Just winning a Superbowl?


Brees and Brady are 2 of the greatest of the last decade and Wilson has outplayed luck every year...

---

I didn't say this year. I said top 5 qbs...

Only Indy fans invent small windows to overrate luck.

Indy are 1-2 outside the useless AFC south

Wel, [BLEEP] then my top 5 is


Manning

Montanna

Marino

Elway

Unitas


They threw away the Philly game. But come on the Denver game was a set-up. Bengals next. When they beat Cincy which they will. Then what say you?

---

I didn't say this year. I said top 5 qbs...


Only Indy fans invent small windows to overrate luck.


Indy are 1-2 outside the useless AFC south

 

Um.... top 5 QBs implies that you are talking about right now and not career achievements. By your logic, Andre Johnson is a top 5 WR.

---

Just winning a Superbowl?

Brees and Brady are 2 of the greatest of the last decade and Wilson has outplayed luck every year...

What has Wilson done better? Besides be on a SB winning team. Dilfer and Brad Johnson did that too.

---

Um.... top 5 QBs implies that you are talking about right now and not career achievements. By your logic, Andre Johnson is a top 5 WR.

 

He's not the smartest, really.

---

He's not the smartest, really.

 

I see that.

---

Um.... top 5 QBs implies that you are talking about right now and not career achievements. By your logic, Andre Johnson is a top 5 WR.

So you base top 5 qbs off a months play?


Did you have billy volek and drew Bennett in your top 5 for a time?


I base my top 5 over at least a seasons worth of play like a normal person...

---

He's not the smartest, really.

I've got a masters degree what's your education?


I'll give luck his due when he strings together a good season...

---

What has Wilson done better? Besides be on a SB winning team. Dilfer and Brad Johnson did that too.

Wins. Ypa, qbr.


Er basically everything...

---