It feels like everyone was spoiled by Luck. Now unless you're the perfect prospect, you aren't a franchise QB. The vast majority of franchise QBs are going to have warts when they come out and it's up to the franchises to build them up.

Luck kinda sucks

---

Luck kinda sucks

 

He kinda doesn't.

---

Luck hasn't lived up to his pre draft hype. There's no denying that.

---

He kinda doesn't.

whatever

---

If Bryce Petty and Mariota declared this year they'd be top 5 picks.

Mariota went to the draft advisory board and then decided to return to school, so no he wouldnt have.

---

It is highly likely Winston will come out in 2015, especially if he wins the heisman and a national title this year.

 

Don't forget a Heisman and national title next year as well.

---

Luck hasn't lived up to his pre draft hype. There's no denying that.

Maybe stats wise, but he did lead his team to the playoffs last year and to a division title this year albeit its a super weak division, and his supporting cast isn't anything spectacular. Honestly, i would gladly give our first and 2nd pick for Luck in a heartbeat.

---

Mariota went to the draft advisory board and then decided to return to school, so no he wouldnt have.

False.

Oregon beat writer Rob Moseley disputes a previous report that stated redshirt sophomore QB Marcus Mariota did not request an evaluation from the NFL Draft Advisory Board. Mariota told Moseley as much. Former NFL scout John Middlekauff cited sources who told him Mariota did not request input from the NFL during his decision making process. Either way, Mariota is staying and we expect him to put forward another great season next year. Dec 7 - 7:12 PM

<a class="bbc_url" href='http://www.rotoworld.com/recent/cfb/131074/marcus-mariota'>http://www.rotoworld.com/recent/cfb/131074/marcus-mariota</a>

---

"Before you criticize a man, walk a mile in his shoes. That way, if he gets angry, he's a mile away and barefoot."

Luck hasn't lived up to his pre draft hype. There's no denying that.

 

Two division titles in two years with absolutely no offensive talent around him (when Reggie Wayne isn't playing) is about all Colts fans could've asked out of Luck after a 2-14 season and jettisoning most of the roster. It doesn't really matter what the media set his hype to be at; he's clearly lived up to his No. 1 billing and is returning on that investment.

 

What Russell Wilson is doing in Seattle is irrelevant to what's going on in Indianapolis, if that's what you're getting at.

---

Luck kinda sucks

 

 

I meant as a prospect. Also it's way to early to write off Luck.

---

Don't forget a Heisman and national title next year as well.

Settle down.

---

Luck hasn't lived up to his pre draft hype. There's no denying that.

 

Completely agree. I also think he benefits from playing in Indianapolis. If he was in DC or NYC, he would not be treated the same.

---

It feels like everyone was spoiled by Luck. Now unless you're the perfect prospect, you aren't a franchise QB. The vast majority of franchise QBs are going to have warts when they come out and it's up to the franchises to build them up.

only the armchair gm's aka message board/sports radio gurus. I doubt anything has changed in the league.

---

Completely agree. I also think he benefits from playing in Indianapolis. If he was in DC or NYC, he would not be treated the same.

 

Yeah, people in New York wouldn't be absolutely smitten by a quarterback who had delivered them two division titles in his first two years in the league. if you think he's overrated now, put his resume in the country's biggest media market and hear how often the term "winner" is thrown around.

---

Why does every QB prospect have to be as NFL ready as Luck or have phenomenal upside like Newton to be considered a 1st overall pick?

---

Yeah, people in New York wouldn't be absolutely smitten by a quarterback who had delivered them two division titles in his first two years in the league. if you think he's overrated now, put his resume in the country's biggest media market and hear how often the term "winner" is thrown around.

he sucks dude

---

Luck hasn't lived up to his pre draft hype. There's no denying that.

 

Really? Takes a 1-15 team and makes the playoffs his first two seasons, winning the division his second year. With a team with a poor defense, no running game, and not the greatest receivers.

 

If that's not living up to the hype your definition of hype differs from most.

---

The sun's not yellow, it's chicken.

he sucks dude

 

Okay, homer.

---

Luck kinda sucks

 

No he really doesn't. 

---

No he really doesn't.

Andrew Suck, amirite

---