Toss up between Tony and Fred. Both of them among the greatest to ever play their respective positions.

My personal bias leans Freddy, history would probably support Tony. Jimmy was an absolute top tier player who could alter the outcome of any game, but he's probably not top ten ever to play his position, especially after the recent golden-era type influx of WR talent (Andre, Megatron, Julio, Green, Brown, we've witnessed some special players at that position over the last decade.).

Freddy's stats might not suggest he's top ten RBs ever, but the eye test does. And if Jim Brown, who I consider the #1 RB ever, says you're the best back in the league while LT, Edge, Gore, Jackson, Faulk, etc are active...well, I'll assume Jim Brown knows more about playing RB than I do. And he singled out a small-market, not perennially Pro-Bowl Freddy as the best. Speaks as highly to me as Munoz saying Tony was the best. Both are studs, both had injury issues in different ways. For me, as RedRooster28, I'll take #28. But Tony was among the best human beings who ever lived at doing what he did as well.

---