(09-04-2017, 10:22 AM)jaglou53 Wrote:

(09-04-2017, 03:29 AM)TheO-LineMatters Wrote: Right now, I have the QB's ranked.......

1. Mason Rudolph (Still my favorite.)

2. Baker Mayfield (I'm surprised I'm saying it, but he looked phenomenal.)

3. Josh Rosen (Forced some throws, but considering the pressure he was under and the hole he was in, it was understandable. What an amazing comeback!)

4. Sam Darnold (I wonder if the pressure of going from a guy to "The Guy", is too much for him. He has all the tools, but may need more time to develop. It'll be interesting to see how he rebounds from a subpar performance.)

5. Luke Falk (It was very hard to judge him. The Cougars didn't need too much to blow out there opponents, so they utilized short passes, runs and a ton of shovel passes. I wanna see him throw the ball downfield. Hopefully I will get to see that next week.)

6. Josh Allen (Ugh! I didn't see anything from him to make me want him at all.)


It's only the first week and undoubtedly my rankings will change, but this week, I saw a lot of good things from several different QB's. Hopefully, we don't screw this up come draft time, because I am seeing some really good talent out there.

Since you like Mayfield so much (I don't disagree), how come McSorley isn't on your list? He is also just 6'0," but has everything else going for him. He also throws a great deep ball and has always been a winner. Depending on where he is ranked at the end of this season, he may also declare for the draft. As a Penn State fan, I hope he returns to State College next season, but the Jaguars could do much worse than him.

For me, it's all about accuracy. Mayfield has been pinpoint accurate for most of his career and last season he completed around 70% of his passes. McSorley on the other hand, is pretty streaky. Last year he couldn't even hit my minimum of 60% pass completions. Combine that with his reported 6' height and I just don't see an NFL QB. For smaller QB's, they need to be accurate and at 6'1" Mayfield shows me what I wanna see.

---