Questions like this are fun to debate, but there are no definitive answers to any of them. The only thing we can say is that the Jaguars terrible record during the past 10 years or so is due to the cumulative effect of all these bad choices. No other team has done such a consistently bad job with their #1 draft picks- not even close. Shack Harris, Gene Smith and Dave Caldwell were all terrible choices, in hindsight, as general managers. If we had to pick the best of these 3, Caldwell would win by a landslide and that is pretty sad considering he's the guy that also hired and extended Gus Bradley's contract and also drafted Bortles. Let's just hope that the law of averages comes into play and Shad hires the right guy as G.M. after this season and he then finds us a quarterback who can finally take the Jaguars to the next level.

---