(11-02-2017, 03:35 PM)JaguarsWoman Wrote:

(11-02-2017, 03:25 PM)Rico Wrote: You were soooooooo sure you were right. 

Consider this: If the Colts had kept Andrew Luck on PUP through Week 6 (they took him off prior to the regular season), he would not have started practicing again until last week. A recent setback followed his limited practices after Week 6. So it is conceivable (not proven, of course) that he would have continued to improve if they had kept him on the PUP list. I am not claiming to know anything, but it would have been safer than going week to week all season.

Consider this. The nature of his injury was basically test it out and either he somehow can play or it's too severe to play for a LONG time. They tested it out. He couldn't even get though a light  practice and you somehow thought he would play soon

---

(11-02-2017, 03:35 PM)JaguarsWoman Wrote:

(11-02-2017, 03:25 PM)Rico Wrote: You were soooooooo sure you were right. 

Consider this: If the Colts had kept Andrew Luck on PUP through Week 6 (they took him off prior to the regular season), he would not have started practicing again until last week. A recent setback followed his limited practices after Week 6. So it is conceivable (not proven, of course) that he would have continued to improve if they had kept him on the PUP list. I am not claiming to know anything, but it would have been safer than going week to week all season.

Consider this. The nature of his injury was basically test it out and either he somehow can play or it's too severe to play for a LONG time. They tested it out. He couldn't even get though a light  practice and you somehow thought he would play soon

---