Login

JackCity · 03-28-2018, 05:00 PM

(03-28-2018, 04:20 PM)Achilles Wrote:
(03-28-2018, 04:00 PM)JackCity Wrote: Okay well for one that isn't true. Damon Harrison is the best run stopping tackle in football. Linval Joseph is #2. Suh is up there. Micheal Pierce is up there.

You thought Suh hasn't been playing well though, when he consistently has been one of the best tackles in football. That leads me to believe you haven't actually watched him.
Here are some extra "stats" for context: Suh 2017: 9 tackles for a loss, 4.5 sacks, 43 pressures all while being an elite top tier run defender on a bad defense. ELITE.

So as I already said , you can keep your Malik>Suh point if you wish. You'd rather Malik, I'd rather Suh.

Dareus is an elite run defender (not the best) but Suh is too. When you add in ALL the extra pass rush and disruption Suh brings over Dareus its pretty inarguable he's a better player at this point and would start for us.

Take off the homer glasses for a bit and be objective. Its fine to think Dareus is very good while also seeing that Suh would start for us. He's a top 10 tackle and one of the best run defenders in football.

I don't even know why you're arguing that. Unless you're saying suh is also better than campbell.

Because you still have Malik and you still have campbell, and Yannick....at that point in time, Suh would only be in the game in certain packages, and we already have dareus to fill that role.

So I guess I would agree that as a rotational DT, Suh would be better than dareus OVERALL, but it isn't really needed, and still not worth the baggage.

And again, you just calling him a top 10 tackle doesn't make it so, neither do pff stats or anything. We will find out this year just how good he is because there is no arguing the talent around him now.

Campbell plays outside like 70% of the time for us.

No if we had Suh our starting Dline would be Calais-Suh-Jackson-Yannick. If you had Suh he'd get more snaps inside than anyone bar Malik.

"I guess I would agree that as a rotational DT, Suh would be better than dareus OVERALL, but it isn't really needed, and still not worth the baggage."

Nope, I never said we needed him and regardless of what way you look at it Suh is a better player than Dareus. Just that saying he wouldn't start here is a ridiculous statement.

I don't use PFF grades. So a question, how do you determine who is a top 10 player or not? Who are your top 10 tackles and why? He's a multiple all pro player.