(04-05-2018, 10:47 AM)pirkster Wrote: I felt that the Colts got the better guy the day he was drafted, regardless of when he was drafted. I thought he looked like a better receiver in blue than our guy did in teal. That opinion was made before he joined our team. He was seen as the better draft prospect and fell to the Colts. Why did he fall? Not sure I've seen anyone tackle that question, but I do believe he was only 19 when drafted and came out a year early.

Interesting thing about opinions, is that they vary (by definition.) I'll eat my crow if I'll have to change mine. I'd expect the humble return in kind should he show out. I'm completely fine if some aren't convinced. I don't feel compelled that you must share my opinion or that I have any obligation to convince anyone else. You're free to have any opinion you like. I respect folks opinions.

(04-05-2018, 12:58 PM)pirkster Wrote: If you all feel so.  I always felt we've overrated ARob for 2015 as Jags fans, and used the "Jaguars don't get credit from the media because we're small market and not winning/not popular" to amplify that sentiment.

I was ready to jump on board in 2017, but he wasn't able to sway me due to not being able to play.  I wish him well and hope he has no setbacks on his recovery.  I still think that will impact his productivity in 2018.

I find this amusing in light of your earlier quip about "facts not caring about our feelings."

By nearly every objective measure, Robinson has been the better player.

He was drafted a full round higher than Moncrief.

He has more catches for more yards and more TDs and more starts over the same time period despite missing virtually all of 2017.

He has more post season awards (1 Pro Bowl to 0 for Moncrief).

https://www.pro-football-reference.com/p...biAl02.htm

https://www.pro-football-reference.com/p...ncDo00.htm

I'm not sure what objective factual criteria you are using to advance the argument that Moncrief is better than Robinson.

---