(04-11-2018, 09:20 PM)flgatorsandjags Wrote:

(04-11-2018, 07:03 AM)JackCity Wrote: Sorry I don't subscribe to WR "wins".  Did he help his team? Yes. The Bucs haven't made the playoffs with Evans. He must not be effective enough.  

Per target efficiency is a very good way to look at how WRs perform. Not as good as the eye test for me but still valuable. "The best ability is availability" is commonly used in football debates when someone is arguing for a lesser player. That's the case here.

I see you skipped the last question, a common tactic of yours. I'll ask again, apart from contested catches (which Odell is very good at) what does Evans do better as a WR? Which technical aspects of the game does he do superior to Odell?

---

Maybe some more hookers and coke would help Evans focus in games more. Or maybe not

Not skipping a question im just moving on.  No matter who you try to "debate" with you always have to get the last word in, the debate would never end.  " The best ability is availability" is commonly used in football debates when one is arguing for one that stays more healthy than the other, common sense really.  I think Evans does every thing better than OBJ other than route running which I would give to Odell, I would give Odell the one handed catches as well.

It's a pretty crucial part of the debate to skip. As well you know. Nobody is making you reply either.

We aren't discussing who has been the healthiest though. We are discussing who is the best. For instance , Linder misses his fair share of games, but if I were comparing his play to another center I would use their on the field play + traits to determine who is better.  

Odell has better hands, better route runner, better at beating press, better running after the catch, better in the short and intermediate. 

Evans is better on jump balls/contested catches, better in the red zone. Both are comparable deep.

---