(12-24-2018, 12:21 PM)JackCity Wrote: 100% yes.  

The most important decisions a GM ever has to make are hiring a HC and drafting a first round QB. Caldwell failed both decisions miserably and then doubled down on the same QB and convinced everyone in the organisation to ride it out with him..we all know how that went.  

There is zero reason to trust him to have any idea how to evaluate a QB.  


His strong points I guess I would say are his ability to get FAs in (although the money helps more) and the mid rounds guys every two years.  I don't think that's enough for everyone to excuse him for how badly he's screwed up the most important position in sports though

Agree with you again.  It's rare for me to agree with you on 2 straight posts

---

(12-24-2018, 12:13 PM)Bullseye Wrote: No.

He's missed on QB, but as I stated in the other thread, this roster is in far better shape than it was when he first got here.

That's not hard to do where we were and where he picked in the draft.  His teams has won no more than 5 games in 4 of the 5 seasons he has been here.  I just have a bit higher standards for this team I guess especially with all the top 5 draft picks we had and possibly getting another with 1 more week left in the regular season

---