(12-30-2018, 05:21 PM)HandsomeRob86 Wrote:

(12-30-2018, 05:13 PM)Upper Wrote: You should have used alcohol as an excuse, the alternative explanations as to how you think Caldwell has picked good everywhere except QB and RB are even worse.

Okay, lemme lay out why I say that-

Lineman - Linder and Robinson are both good
WR- ARob, Westbrook, and Hurns, Lee to a lesser extend
RB- Yeldon is okay, Fournette is looking like a bust
CB- Ramsey, plus Colvin in the past
LB - Jack and Telvin are decent.
d-line - Ngakowae and Fowler were good. Smoot has looked better this year but he is still in the wait and see. Bryan, we will just have to see.
Safety - Harrison has actually looked awesome.

The positions I think he hasn't been good on:
QB - Bortles - backup level bust
RB - Yeldon - serviceable change of pace back, Fournette just isn't available and isn't good enough when he is.
TE- I can't think of anyone we drafted
FB - cause we drafted one at all.

He hasn't been bad. Several of the players in the top list have been pro-bowlers or are at least near that level. The problem is that he hasn't got the QB, and he also messed up on a 1st round RB (so far).

Robinson is not as good as people make him out to be. Boselli has been highly critical of his work ethic and footwork. He is a concern.
2 of the WR's you named aren't on the roster anymore. If they were good, a good GM finds a way to keep them.  Westbrook is a #3 receiver in the NFL.
Colvin was slightly above average
Telvin has regressed significantly. I'll put this on the coaches and loss of Poz.
Harrison has potential.
Yeldon will be a huge star in another offense.

---

(12-30-2018, 05:23 PM)JagFan81 Wrote: What do you guys think we'll do with OC. We're going for continuity, and I'm guessing that applies to gameplan and systems so how much control or room will they have? 

I'm looking more at an inside hire or someone from TC's history. 

I see the logic, there's going to be an incredible amount of pressure and expectation next season. The hope is they can get the players focused again.

Not only that. If they keep Wash as the DC, that is almost as insane as keeping Marrone.

---