(01-29-2019, 01:20 PM)jradMITEX Wrote:

(01-29-2019, 11:54 AM)IfdB2hibry Wrote: The issue is your assumption and blindness to one side in defense of the other. I and many others don't relieve Trump of blame. They are all to blame. The issue is when you illogically assign blame to just him when there are obvious factors in play well before he gets involved. It is also intellectually dishonest to assign blame because of words used in an effort to negotiate. When did words start meaning more than actions? And no the bill signed was not the same as the bill offered in early December. That has been discussed and shown ad nauseum. The original bipartisan bill included $25B and yanked by Schumer. This is how we got in this mess! Trump eventually signing this current CR was not a matter of ratings or ego or whatever smoke and mirror you want to throw out there. It was a frustrated F-you to both sides of the aisle to get paychecks back in the hands of Federal workers. Enough was enough and the opportunity to negotiate and compromise on a bipartisan bill had run its course. Shutdown precedents is a lame excuse. This was not the first shutdown (Jimmy Carter(D), Reagan®, Bush®, Cinton(D), Obama(D), Trump®. Hey look, the only thing bipartisan related to shutdowns!

I agree, Pelosi refusing SOTU was purely political. Nothing of value in that move. She will forever be engrained in history as the first speaker to deny the POTUS a SOTU address in what had become the new norm of upholding the POTUS's constitutional responsibility of addressing Congress. Sure he could submit it in writing but don't you think the American people deserve to be intuned as well? It is one of a few times where all three branches of government are assembled together. Heck, even George Washington delivered his amongst a joint session.

I think you are operating on a strong assumption of your own, like these elected officials are doing the bidding of the American people. As evident on this board, the general public is somewhat clueless as to what is really going on in those chambers outside of what their favorite media outlet tells them. Few tune in to watch floor discussions or votes anymore. Few actually goe and read the Bills full text and amendments. This shutdown was a sad example of blind loyalty to party with a few defectors on both sides. There was blatant ignoring of Department funding requests, committee appropriations submittals/approvals, and executive appropriations reports/requests. All of the previously mentioned had border security funding to include mix methods (including barrier structures). This was not the sole request from the President or his pet project. This was at the request of Border Protection and their parent DHS. This funding request was a continuation from previously approved funding of barriers and sector protections that goes back multiple Presidencies. This is not a popularity issue and is pure obstructionism based on misinformation and partisanship. Probably still people thinking $5B+ is strictly for a wall. Their is no logical defense of how this shutdown occurred and the resist behavior of the House. In my opinion, DHS funding has been steadily rejected due to wanting an increase in ICE operations/funding. The wall is just an emotionally driven excuse. What does a Supreme Court nominee have to do with border security and government funding?

Do you understand that there is already multiple cases of precedents involving declaring a National Emergency in regards to immigration and/or border security? Probably not. The National Emergencies power is given to the President by Congress and there are currently upwards of 30 still in effect! If Congress doesn't want to give the POTUS this broad Constitutional statutory power, then they need to vote to revoke. I think most folks would be suprised to learn just what is available to the President when declaring a National Emergency. Want to scare yourself, you need to research PEADs or Presidential Emergency Action Documents. You might be able to find a few "cleared" archived documents that are usually Close Hold. As far as my blind loyalty, that has been and will be for the United States and the Constitution, not political party or figurehead.

Who holds the cards and who wins or loses is a matter of perspective. Unfortunately, most points of view are politicaly skewed and misinformed. Only the citizens suffer for the broad stupidity. Who would of thought the sovereignty and safety of our citizens was/is debatable?

https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/...ection.pdf

https://www.dhs.gov/sites/default/files/...202019.pdf

https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/up...curity.pdf

If there is such an emergency and such precedent, then what is the hold up?  Why wait if this is so straightforward, common, and pressing?  Every minute of delay just bolsters the argument that there isn't an emergency if it is so easy why shut down the government for 35+ days?  if what you assert is true then the presidents actions are baffling and illogical.   This board is not a complete reflection of society or the opinion of the country which after numerous polls has shown consistently that a majority of the country is against the wall, pick a time, a year ago, before the shutdown and after, still a majority oppose the wall.   You can blame a lack of an immigration deal on all parties involved, I guess even though Republicans have repeatedly been the ones to tank the big bipartisan immigration bills out of appeasement to the base, however, this shutdown was 100% on Trump.  He could have easily of signed the CR in December and continued to make his public push.  He thought the shutdown gave him leverage for some idiotic reason when in fact it has weakened him politically.  Negotiating during a shutdown would have just invited more down the road.   This is 100% about a wall ok maybe just 99% if he would have dropped the wall precondition he could easily have gotten the money for other border security measures and investments.  It's quite incredulous to suggest that the wall isn't the crux of the matter, it was heavily sold on the campaign, he repeatedly suggested that without it we will be overrun by drugs and crime.  Build the wall and crime will fall right?  

BTW Pelosi didn't prevent him completely from giving the SOTU, just during the shutdown, and low and behold its back on.  She'll go down in history all right, as the first Speaker to win a shutdown and the one who made Trump cave after the longest shutdown in history.

This isn't difficult. He owes it to Congress to let them do their job. You can cite all the polls you'd like about what people think about a "wall". It's about border security that includes multiple measures as identified by the responsible agency, not what Jenny from Maine thinks about the wall. The Dems have pushed over and over that the "wall" is evil/immoral and the media have parroted the same. The slow thinkers have now latched onto that saggy teat. I feel like a broken record on here even after providing fact after fact and link after link. The fact remains, no measure implemented alone at the border will work or stand on its own as an effective deterrent. They must be used in concert with all the other pieces. Only under this President have the Dems walked back on that thought and held funding hostage. I agree though, for the Dems, it is 100% about a wall but for the Reps and those that pay attention, it is about border security.

I feel like you just type your emotional thoughts on here with zero understanding of reality and 100% opinion. You're entitled and I get that. However, it feels like no effort has been given by you to research outside of your emotional opinion or what your party tells you. I even tried to offer up documentation to help you along the way. At this point, I'll let you believe what you believe and grasp partisan rhetoric as fact. I can't waste time offering up information you could find on your own, only to have you just dismiss it.

Yeah, Pelosi wins a shutdown . She really is a shining example and showed women how not to be bullied by a man...etc, etc. All her old, rich, white millionaire friends will be sure to send her thank you cards for the continuance of cheap immigrant day labor. I wouldn't hold your breath for yours!

---