Josh Allen - A - Ed Oliver would have gotten my A+ grade, but the second best player on the board at a premium position is very good. Especially considering the other non Oliver options were a big drop off.
Jawaan Taylor - C - Fine value on talent alone, but several red flags and the cementing of our stone age offense makes this far from the home run many say. Especially considering they traded up only to have Ford and Risner go at the original pick and two picks later.
Josh Oliver - C - Again, fine value in a vacuum, but man there were a lot of better players on the board. Also a weird fit to draft a poor blocker right after the dominant run blocking tackle in the draft.
Quincy Williams - D - When draftniks who ranked 300 and 500 total players say they don't know who it is, and when the player drafted says he was preparing his list of potential UDFA landing spots, maybe you reached...a lot.
Ryquell Armstead - D - A big, straight line fast, stiff, inefficient power back...where have we heard that before? Oh yeah. There were a lot of quality change of pace backs that could have fit the bill for this team much better.
Gardner Minshew - D- - A guy who has at best long term backup potential just doesn't excite me. Especially when there were some very toolsy lottery ticket QBs still on the board.
Dontavius Russell - C - Whatever. A backup run stuffer.

Very opposite of our normal drafts, where we blow the first picks and finish strong. Dave started with a bang and then progressively fell off the cliff this year. Since we so often use baseball analogies to describe the draft, we started the draft with a leadoff triple...but merely got a sacrifice fly to bring the run in before whimpering out the rest of the game.

---