(10-26-2019, 06:55 PM)flgatorsandjags Wrote:

(10-26-2019, 07:03 AM)hb1148 Wrote: Surprisingly, that's actually arguable. I haven't watched Mayfield play much outside of highlights but statistically there's not much to choose between the two this year.

He said rookie QBs.  You dont think Mayfield had a better year last year than Minshew is this year?  Hes not better this year but he had a better rookie year

We won't know until the year's through but if you extrapolate, you can certainly make the case for one or the other. Mayfield in 14 games might have a couple hundred more passing yards in 34 more attempts then Minshew in his rookie year and probably more TDs but Minshew would probably end up with fewer INTs. Circumstances are different, the players are different, the teams are different.  Also Minshew may not get to 14 starts if Foles comes back.

---