Quote:Just go ahead and take a QB from a weak class. You can't afford to pass.


Signed,


Josh Freeman

Mark Sanchez

Geno Smith

Jamarcus Russel

Vince Young

Matt Leinart

Byron Leftwich

David Carr

Joey Harrington

Tim Couch

Akili Smith

Cade McNown

Ryan Leaf

Heath Schuler

Rick Mirer

David Klingler

Andre Ware

...


In the case of Leftwich, it cost selecting Roethlisberger the following year. The same situation we may be facing if we reach for a QB with pick #3 this year.


Take a QB this year. Even two if you like. But rest assured there will likely be a much better selection of QBs to choose from next year.


That's why I believe the wisest move would be to look for a QB in the second or third, and pick up another developmental QB later between 5-7 or UDFA.


The thing about "needing" a QB, is that it is never "now or never." You get to draft players every year. No one is stopping you from taking a QB. You can't fear passing on a guy who you don't feel is the right value. That causes you to choose guys from the above list instead of Wilsons and Kaepernicks. Have the stones to pass if the value isn't right. You will find one as long as you do your homework and don't panic reaching for a "must have" QB that's not really so "must have" after all.

What is that list supposed to prove? That some qbs have been busts? K, great point.


You keep saying "reach" when no one is saying that. You have some weird belief that everyone is qb or bust. Most of us think teddy or another qb is worth a top 5 pick. That's only "reaching" in your because you don't like the qbs.


Lol that doesn't cause you to choose between the Wisons and Kaps. Keep trying to follow that plan of just flat out getting lucky. Gms just missed on those two players and San Fran and Seattle got extremely lucky (I'm still hesitant to say Kap is franchise qb).


What happens next year when only a few qbs declare and we finish outside the top 10? Trade everything to go up and grab a qb or hope one magically falls to us?

---