In my opinion Caldwell has done well.
And there's reason to believe he's getting better at his job as he goes.
I don't think Dave knows how to pair those players up with the coaches that will get the most out of them however.
So I don't think Dave should pick the next coach.
If I were Shad Khan, I would quietly build a little board of retired guys with NFL coaching experience, or NFL playing experience, and have those guys interview some of the key players that we know are going to be in Jacksonville for the next three or four years. Guys like Josh Allen, Minshew, Chark, Jawaan Taylor, Myles Jack, etc. then I would interview three or four head coaching candidates, asking most of the questions, but giving these guys on the board a chance to see the interviews and comment. The board should end up with a pretty strong opinion of which coach has the best chance to get the most out of the good players that I have

---