Quote:Geno Smith wasn't playing against the likes of Alabama, LSU, Auburn, etc.... The teams he played as well as his own regularly gave up 30 - 40 points every week.


Also, when evaluating Johnny after the season was over and I started reviewing games I realized his success wasn't just from Mike Evans.


Johnny completed 300 passes for 4114 yards and mike Evans only accounted for 69 of those completions for 1394 yards....Thats not a dominating amount of production as say i.e. Sammy Watkins is for Tahj Boyd...


What is it that you don't like about Johnny Football?


Also, you keep saying don't count on college success. But Bridgewater dominated 15-30 yard accuracy charts....isn't that based on college success.......

Lets call a spade a spade


Bamas d was exposed for average against the sooners


Auburns defense was below average


The one defense that was actual quality was lsu, we saw how that went


Also your just evaluating stats, not how he got them. If stats was the tell all, case keenum would have been the first qb off the board 2012


The fact of the matter is that he misses alot of PRIMARY reads reads in the sumlin system, his mechanics are in consistent and he has no pocket presence.


Thats not first round material let alone top 10 material


Bridgewater is playing within his system (which is used in the pros)


He makes the right reads and he makes the right throws


He reads the entire field and has borderline genius football iq


He dominates the short to intermediate game even under the offensive restrictions he is under


No other qb deserves a 1st round look

---