(09-08-2020, 12:40 PM)imtheblkranger Wrote:

(09-08-2020, 12:29 PM)Cleatwood Wrote: Or is it because he’s more mobile and makes throws only 3 QBs in this league can make? Murray’s ceiling is extremely high where as Minshews is Ryan Fitzpatrick (saw someone say this earlier and it’s spot on).

Some of you are really over inflating this team and it’s comical. They were ready to sign Clowney and trade him to Baltimore for a draft pick. They’re tanking and it’s looking like Caldwell will be back no matter what. You don’t make these moves without the assurance you’ll be back. There’s a reason the Jags are constantly mocked around the league and projected to pick 1st in 2021.

It's hard for me to say the guy who played better last year (Minshew) is worse. Sure Murray can make some throws others can't, that doesn't mean he's the better QB.

After this season we'll have a better idea, but right now Minshew is a more successful NFL QB.

Ya know... Murray even prepared all last off season to be the starter. And his HC tailor made an offense for him straight outta his college playbook.
I mean, I'm not saying Minshew will be a HoF QB but the idea that Murray is going to make some astronomical jump in his 2nd year is pretty assumptive. Murray has some skills that Minshew does not possess certainly... but his play last season was "meh" for most games. And his surrounding roster wasn't much worse than ours, if at all.
I can not wait to compare all the 2019 rookie QBs after this season and perhaps the next. That's when we'll really know.

---