Caldwell should never get another job as a GM again. He is a decent scout in the later rounds but can't be trusted to make a pick early in the draft.

Think about how many 1st and 2nd rounders are no longer on the team with his 8 years here. It's really bad.

Look at the 1st rounders left on the team. None are close to superstar status.

I argue that Caldwell was worse for this franchise than Gene Smith. Caldwell had 8 years and outside of 1 kept this team a bottom feeder. I don't even credit him with the playoff run because Coughlin was the man in charge.

---