(12-01-2020, 07:13 PM)jaguarmvp Wrote: Caldwell should never get another job as a GM again. He is a decent scout in the later rounds but can't be trusted to make a pick early in the draft.  

Think about how many 1st and 2nd rounders are no longer on the team with his 8 years here.  It's really bad.

Look at the 1st rounders left on the team. None are close to superstar status.

I argue that Caldwell was worse for this franchise than Gene Smith.   Caldwell had 8 years and outside of 1 kept this team a bottom feeder. I don't even credit him with the playoff run because Coughlin was the man in charge.

The reason the first rounders that were good aren’t here is Coughlin. Remember Caldwell drafted Ramsey, who is a hall of fame level player. Just cause he isn’t on our team anymore doesn’t mean that was Caldwells fault. He also drafted multiple pro bowl level players. Gene best draft pick was probably Alualu, who was a long term backup. The rest of his guys were out of the league within a few years. Anyone who compares Caldwell to Gene has no clue. Gene was the all time worst GM in just about every facet.

---