(05-12-2021, 03:04 PM)JagFanatic24 Wrote:

(05-12-2021, 01:37 PM)JagFan81 Wrote: Great list and idea. Will need a bit of time to think and read about.

One quick question, are you ranking players in terms of pure talent or by how big of an impact they had for us. Or a mix of both?

For example I think in terms of pure talent, Ramsey should be high, I have plenty of issues with him but hes one of the most naturally gifted players I've seen. But Poz did 10 times as much for us as he did.

Thanks.

Thanks man. I ranked them on the impact they made on the field. 

@NC thank you for that list. I was speaking of 1st team all pro.

It's not a bad list.  The order of many could easily be debated.  I think you over-rated players who were really good for a short period of time and under-rated players who contributed over the long haul.  For example, you have Calais Campbell ranked in the very high 12th spot despite only being with the team 3 years with 1 of those seasons not being all that great.  Remove the 2017 season from his resume and I doubt you would have even remotely considered him for the top 25.  Brad Meester holds the team record for playing 14 seasons and 211 games and he didn't even make your list.  Is Bouye's 43 games worth more than Naeole's 87 games or Manuwai's 111 games?  I think interior offensive line got overlooked.  If it's contributions to the team (and not just pure talent), I think Marcedes Lewis is one who you also have to include.  He's actually ranked 3rd all time in receiving yards for the Jaguars and 2nd all time in receiving touchdowns.  Overall though, not bad.

---