Trump's plan and Biden's plan both hinged on the ANA keeping Kabul secure for at least a little while.
Neither of them would have been able to make the ANA do something that it did not want to do.
Biden has refused to take responsibility, saying it is the ANAs fault. Trump obviously would have done exactly the same thing, he would not have taken responsibility for this. I think it goes without saying that Trump's rhetoric would be even more rude and even less helpful than Biden's has been.
One of them might have been more nimble than the other to get more Americans out faster.
But you guys saying that this is all going to lead to Harris taking over are way out to lunch. You looked at Biden's age before he even began his administration and said that this has to end with Harris taking over. Now every thing that goes wrong is just confirmation of your prophecy. It's not that different from how I looked at how Trump treated the Establishment Republicans and I concluded that the establishment Republicans would turn on him and remove him from office sooner rather than later. Every little thing that happened, from 2017 to 2020 was, for me, just the next sign that Trump was on his way out. Take it from me guys, don't be like that.

---