(02-11-2022, 03:30 PM)VBE Wrote:

(02-11-2022, 09:32 AM)Mikey Wrote: (Myles Jack wasn't down)

---

I'm not familiar with whatever play you're referring to, I'm assuming it was a play from the AFCCG? Either way though, I don't think the Eagles would have lost LII regardless of who the opponent from the AFCCG was. I'm obviously biased, but I was supremely confident that 2017 was 'my year' (yes, mine) from the point where the Eagles kicked the 61 yard FG to beat the Giants, onward. Even after Wentz went down, I had 100% faith and confidence in Nick Foles taking the Eagles on a run that would lead all the way to the "Rocky Steps", and I'm not just saying that 'after the fact'. Members on the EMB can fully attest to that lol. 

But I'd hope that Jags fans don't hold on to a play of that sort, the way sad Cowboys fans hold on to the Dez Bryant incompletion. Every team, every year has plays that get called in such a way that you can say it was a bad call or a play that you say 'what if'. What if Randall Cunningham doesn't get hit directly on his knee by Bryce Paup, in the 1991 opener vs. the Packers? 

1991 was arguably that eras Eagles best shot at getting to and potentially winning a Lombardi. They had one of the greatest D's of all time, a QB who could pass and run (when properly coached) and a good run game. But first play of the 2nd quarter of the first game of the season, Cunningham gets his knee blown out by a helmet hitting directly on it and the season is lost. But despite having to use 5 different starting QB's throughout that season, they still finished 10-6. A lot of Eagles fans have held on to that 'what if' for a lot of years. It's meaningless, though. 

"What if's", never were.

On the "Myles Jack wasn't down" play, Myles Jack appeared to have recovered a fumble and gotten touched by a member of the Patriots when he was down, but replay showed he was still bobbling the ball when he was touched.   So technically, he wasn't down.  Then he got up and ran for a TD, but the play had been blown dead.  And you can't overturn a whistle.  

We had plenty of other chances to win that game.  We let Tom Brady complete a 19 yard pass on 3rd and 18, for example.  Just stopping that one play would have won us the game.  My memory of that game was not of the officials making a bad call.  What I remember is us allowing the Pats to come back, when we had plenty of opportunities on defense to make the one play that would have sealed the game for us. 

Would we have beaten the Eagles in the Super Bowl?  That would have meant Blake Bortles winning a Super Bowl.  Looking back on it, that seems pretty far-fetched.  

For long time Jags fans, a far more painful loss was the 1999 AFC Championship Game in our own stadium.   We went 15-3 including the playoffs that year.  We beat the Dolphins and Dan Marino/Jimmy Johnson the week prior 62-7.  Then we lost to our biggest, most hated rival, the Titans, in the AFCCG the very next week.  We lost 3 total games that season, all to the same team- the Titans.  That 1999 team was far better than the 2017 team.  That loss in the 1999 AFCCG was by far the most painful loss for me in my life.

---