(02-20-2022, 06:53 PM)Cleatwood Wrote:

(02-20-2022, 05:46 PM)flgatorsandjags Wrote: Those aren't HOF players. Mahomes also has Andy Reid
Being Brady retired, because of course he is at the top,  I'd probably go

1. Allen
2. Rodgers 
3. Mahomes
4. Burrow
5. Herbert

Just curious. What makes Rodgers better than Mahomes? He has a HOF WR on his team and yet can’t even make it to a SB in a far weaker conference than Mahomes.

To be honest, not sure you can have a wrong QB list unless your Acho who didn’t even include Mahomes in the top 5 which is ludicrous.

I think it’s a bit of regency bias here. Mahomes played his worst half of football in the AFC title game but when he beats Allen in the playoffs, we disregard that? Allen is really good. No doubt. But not sure anyone can claim he’s better than Mahomes when he can’t beat him.

I think accuracy and what he has to work with.  Rodgers does have a ring and is a 4 time MVP.  I think if Rodgers had Kelce on that team and his top lineman they would of won the SB.  He beat Allen but it wasn't Allen's fault.  Allen had 9 TDs and 12 incompletions in his 2 playoff games.  Kelce was wide open for a reason I'll never understand and the Bills defense was to slow for Hill.  Mahomes looks like Brees and Rodgers, can't get it done when it matters the most.

---

Every year the Packers do nothing to help Rodgers, draft a QB in the 1st. Every year the Chiefs load up on offense and do everything the can whether it be a RB in the 1st, WR in the 2nd, trade for a Pro Bowl LT and load up on the oline. Packers need to do more to help Rodgers on offense

---