Quote:Weren't Duper/ Clayton known for being one of the all-time great WR duos in NFL history?.... :ermm:

So, you don't have a problem with Duper being in the Dolphins RoH? Well, then surely you wouldn't object to McCardell being in the Pride.

 

In six seasons in Jacksonville McCardell recorded 499 receptions for 6,393 yards and 30 touchdowns.

In eleven seasons in Miami Duper recorded 511 receptions for 8,869 yards and 59 touchdowns.

 

That means that in five extra seasons Duper managed a whole 12 extra receptions, 2,476 yards, and 29 touchdowns.

If we use McCardell's six seasons as a baseline (and say he only halved his usual production for those five extra seasons)  he would have 704 receptions, 9053 yards, and 43 touchdowns.

If we use McCardell's six seasons as a baseline and don't halve his production he ends up with 914 receptions, 11718 yards, and 55 touchdowns.

 

Oh, and in 11 seasons with the Jags, Smith outperformed Duper in receptions, yards, and touchdowns. Yet you're "on the fence" about him, but are fine with calling Duper/Clayton one of the greatest duos and having them in the RoH of the Dolphins.

 

Smith and McCardell outperformed Duper and Clayton without having one of the best QBs of all time throwing them the ball.

 

Quote:...and I've been on record with saying Jimmy deserves to be in. Certainly more so than Brunell. 

 

Actually, you said that you'd be on the fence about his inclusion into the pride.

 

Quote:Jimmy Smith would be more deserving than Brunell.....and I'd still be on the fence regarding Jimmy's inclusion into the Pride. 

 

Why? Because of his off the field issues? Well, if you're going to count that against Smith wouldn't it only make sense to count Brunell's positive off the field impacts for him?

---