(08-22-2023, 11:17 PM)NYC4jags Wrote:

(08-22-2023, 04:16 PM)rpr52121 Wrote: Not specifically. It will definitely be at least 6-8 weeks which is what it would take for a patellar dislocation or say a tiny avulsion fracture. Most other patellar injuries would take a few months and probably end the season for an offensive lineman who has to be in a particular stance and putting a lot a weight and force through the knee consistently. And yes, a patellar tendon tear could be career ending depending on severity and recovery.


It depends how quickly they started to ice it during the game to reduce the swelling. A lot of newer stadiums have an MRI machine in house or right next door these days, but sometimes these are only available for the home teams. There are certain "tests/maneuvers" you they can do to look for obvious injuries like a bad patellar tendon tear or fracture. But as those are pretty obvious and would end his season, I would presume that would have leaked out from Saturday and be widespread knowledge by now. You can still do the MRI even with swelling, but sometimes it can affect the accuracy of intensity assessments or 50/50 calls of certain injuries. Plus the coil they have to put over the knee has to fit well to get a good image and that may be tough to tolerate.


I just find this argument kind of silly. Because every team operates like this, so it is not hard for other teams to predict how other teams are playing this and what any particular statement means. Plus it is not like they don't know he has a patella injury. He is going to be out for 6 weeks to the full season, and every situation in that range means the Jags will have him on some injury list and need to replace that spot. 

It's not like hockey where they say he a lower body injury or a torso injury, and that's it. Even there leaks happen all the time, so most people eventually find out enough specifics to strategize.

On top of all it, it just causes fans, reporters, and talking heads to speculate non stop which in the end doesn't help anyone. In some cases it can very much hurt the player's reputation too, like with Coughlin's lies about Fred Taylor's injuries. As betting starts getting bigger and bigger, I think the NFL will finally have financial incentive to just make all of this very straightforward.

That's cool.

Why do YOU think the team decided not to talk about injuries after joint practices and again after a preseason game this week when they've talked openly about them in every other presser all summer?

(08-22-2023, 08:01 PM)NYC4jags Wrote:

(08-22-2023, 03:53 PM)rpr52121 Wrote: Are you sure the it is the tendon and not the bone?

I can only find 1 report that specifies tendon. Everything else just says patella.

Just quoting the report from the team to a team employee who posted it on SM