<div> 

Quote:<div>
His film is not that solid, esp this previous year. I see flashes of greatness but not consistency.

His presnap adjustments are good but he also changes to the wrong play a lot of times as well.


I see him throw with anticipation at times, but a majority of the time he is throwing to open guys and not throwing them open.


I see great accuracy at times, but there are also a lot of balls that aren't accurate at all....


I have also seen a lot if check down passes, which wouldn't be a big deal, but considering how open he is use to having his guys it makes me feel he won't throw a ball that is open by NFL standards and become a captain check down if forced to start right away....


 

</div>
</div>

Quote:How can you POSSIBLY know this?!? (referring to the part in bold)

 

To know this, you'd have to, at minimum, know:

 

1)  Exactly which play was called, including applicable blocking schemes, route combinations, and reads;

 

2)  Exactly what the defense was showing pre-snap...what keys the defense showed to trigger the audible;

 

3)  The audibles available to him-whether pre-set or whether he is fee to choose whatever play he wanted given the personnel.

 

4)  Exactly what play the audible switched to, including applicable blocking schemes, route combinations, and reads;

 

5)  Whether the defense remained the same or switched in response to the audible;

 

6)  Exactly what play the defense switched to, including line action, potential blitzes, underneath coverages, etc.

 

I don't know how you can know any of this without knowing at least one of the playbooks.

 

I know because on the video(s) I can see him changing the play at the line of scrimmage. You know talking to his O-line and other teammates and pointing out stuff in the defense........

 

Why would I need to know the playbook to know whether or not he is changing the play/ or at the very least doing dummy calls? Like I said sometimes he does this and it works out perfectly, and other times it doesn't.

 

 

By the way this is considered as one his strengths by various members of this board. They will point out that he is great in his pre-snap reads and adjustments (i.e. audibles) to put his team in the best play possible. So the question I have is if they can see that on the video, how come I can't see the negatives of this on video????

---